Suaal: Mowliid & Christmas

[Shirib]

So this question goes to those who celebrate Mowliid.

Is Christmas halaal? Since we're allowed to celebrate the birth of Mohamed, what about the birth of Isa?

[BlackVelvet]

Fabulous idea! We could all go to midnight mass and light a few candles...

[Ka darag]

Sing a few carols too .

[Shirib]

Sing a few carols too .

People do that in mowliid. why not christmas?

[youtube]ncQi1FGYL9U&playnext=1&list=PLE7F989369967DAE9&index=44[/youtube]

[grandpakhalif]

First of all Christmas is not Nabi Cisse's birthday, it's a pagan ritual which has been practiced since the 1200's, its traditionn is to celebrate the Winter Solistice, the church later adapted this for various reasons. Now it's a commercial ploy used to make children coherce their parents to purchase items.

Nabi Rasullahi SCWS, birthday is completely different and it is an insult you compare the two. Shows your lack of knowledge on Islam. It seems your mocking the great practice of Mowliid to score a few cheap points. How despicable.

[Mzbeautifull]

I wouldn't mind some nice turkey dinner with gravy

[Ka darag]

I wouldn't mind some nice turkey dinner with gravy

[Executive]

First of all Christmas is not Nabi Cisse's birthday, it's a pagan ritual which has been practiced since the 1200's, its traditionn is to celebrate the Winter Solistice, the church later adapted this for various reasons. Now it's a commercial ploy used to make children coherce their parents to purchase items.

Nabi Rasullahi SCWS, birthday is completely different and it is an insult you compare the two. Shows your lack of knowledge on Islam. It seems your mocking the great practice of Mowliid to score a few cheap points. How despicable.

So would you celebrate Nab Cisse's birthday?


Mowlid was first celebrated by Shia who wanted to copy the Christians they saw celebrating Christmas.

[1-Londoner]

Fabulous idea! We could all go to midnight mass and light a few candles...

Anyway....shame on you people. Bidcadan aad soo wada tuureysaan maxaa kugu salidey?? Prophets Birthdays kulaha...

[AhlulbaytSoldier]

Sir you are dumb. Christmas has nothing to do with Isa/Jesus aleyhi salaam. Its an pagan day.

[Shirib]

First of all Christmas is not Nabi Cisse's birthday, it's a pagan ritual which has been practiced since the 1200's, its traditionn is to celebrate the Winter Solistice, the church later adapted this for various reasons. Now it's a commercial ploy used to make children coherce their parents to purchase items.

Nabi Rasullahi SCWS, birthday is completely different and it is an insult you compare the two. Shows your lack of knowledge on Islam. It seems your mocking the great practice of Mowliid to score a few cheap points. How despicable.

For all extensive purposes Christmas is to commemorate the birth of Isa AS, like Mowliid is for Muhammad SAW. Neither date is probably exact.

But why is celebrating the so called birth of Jesus haraam, and that of Muhammad halaal? They were both prophets of Allah. We're supposed to love and adore both of them.

[Mzbeautifull]

First of all Christmas is not Nabi Cisse's birthday, it's a pagan ritual which has been practiced since the 1200's, its traditionn is to celebrate the Winter Solistice, the church later adapted this for various reasons. Now it's a commercial ploy used to make children coherce their parents to purchase items.

Nabi Rasullahi SCWS, birthday is completely different and it is an insult you compare the two. Shows your lack of knowledge on Islam. It seems your mocking the great practice of Mowliid to score a few cheap points. How despicable.

For all extensive purposes Christmas is to commemorate the birth of Isa AS, like Mowliid is for Muhammad SAW. Neither date is probably exact.

But why is celebrating the so called birth of Jesus haraam, and that of Muhammad halaal? They were both prophets of Allah. We're supposed to love and adore both of them.

I never even knew Muslims celebrated Mohammeds birthday

[grandpakhalif]

First of all Christmas is not Nabi Cisse's birthday, it's a pagan ritual which has been practiced since the 1200's, its traditionn is to celebrate the Winter Solistice, the church later adapted this for various reasons. Now it's a commercial ploy used to make children coherce their parents to purchase items.

Nabi Rasullahi SCWS, birthday is completely different and it is an insult you compare the two. Shows your lack of knowledge on Islam. It seems your mocking the great practice of Mowliid to score a few cheap points. How despicable.

For all extensive purposes Christmas is to commemorate the birth of Isa AS, like Mowliid is for Muhammad SAW. Neither date is probably exact.

But why is celebrating the so called birth of Jesus haraam, and that of Muhammad halaal? They were both prophets of Allah. We're supposed to love and adore both of them.

No I would not celebrate it on Christmas but if his exact date was given I would simply fast in remembrance for he is not a prophet sent to my people but the people of bani israel.

[Shirib]

First of all Christmas is not Nabi Cisse's birthday, it's a pagan ritual which has been practiced since the 1200's, its traditionn is to celebrate the Winter Solistice, the church later adapted this for various reasons. Now it's a commercial ploy used to make children coherce their parents to purchase items.

Nabi Rasullahi SCWS, birthday is completely different and it is an insult you compare the two. Shows your lack of knowledge on Islam. It seems your mocking the great practice of Mowliid to score a few cheap points. How despicable.

For all extensive purposes Christmas is to commemorate the birth of Isa AS, like Mowliid is for Muhammad SAW. Neither date is probably exact.

But why is celebrating the so called birth of Jesus haraam, and that of Muhammad halaal? They were both prophets of Allah. We're supposed to love and adore both of them.

I never even knew Muslims celebrated Mohammeds birthday

They go to the misaajids. Eat, lecture and have hadra's.



Remind u of something else?

[yunis09]

I never even knew Muslims celebrated Mohammeds birthday

i felt like that 6 years ago

shrib, i see the point you are making here, so i wont bother in answering the question!