Isaaq Historian Xplaya deservers a Medal for his work

[samatar133]

Tankar
what is the diference between Ina Cabdille Xasan iyo Ina Cabdi Godane?
Do you also idolise Godane and his ALshabaab fighters?

[grandpakhalif]

Sayidka will always be remembered as the evictor of Christians in British Somaliland.

[samatar133]

Sayidka will always be remembered as the evictor of Christians in British Somaliland.

Siigayste and Godane will both be remembered as terrorists who committed unspeakable atrocities against somali people in the name of defending Islam

[grandpakhalif]

ceeb qof dhintay ha caayin, wa bisha barakaysan

[samatar133]

ceeb qof dhintay ha caayin, wa bisha barakaysan

A cruel terrorist does not deserve to be respected ever if he dead

[Tanker]

Tankar
what is the diference between Ina Cabdille Xasan iyo Ina Cabdi Godane?
Do you also idolise Godane and his ALshabaab fighters?

You can not compare the dervish with al shabab its just silly, the dervish were sufi muslims who had many female fighters they were tolerant towards female rights, al shabab view females as animals, the dervish were supported by somali tribal leaders, somali youth, somali females, the al shabab is just a bunch of thugs and criminals from pakistan, arabia, somalia, they don't have any agenda or goal and they don't have support from somali muslim public they only know how to blow up civilians and flees from foreign troops like true cowards the dervish were lions who never ran away

[CaliBurco]

Lol, the mad mullah died running.

[Khalid Ali]

Tankar
what is the diference between Ina Cabdille Xasan iyo Ina Cabdi Godane?
Do you also idolise Godane and his ALshabaab fighters?

You can not compare the dervish with al shabab its just silly, the dervish were sufi muslims who had many female fighters they were tolerant towards female rights, al shabab view females as animals, the dervish were supported by somali tribal leaders, somali youth, somali females, the al shabab is just a bunch of thugs and criminals from pakistan, arabia, somalia, they don't have any agenda or goal and they don't have support from somali muslim public they only know how to blow up civilians and flees from foreign troops like true cowards the dervish were lions who never ran away

Maybe you dont know much about dervishes but they were takfiries any one who didn't supported them was a gaal an infidel and deserved to be killed their woman to be taken their stock to be looted. If the dervishes had detonators in the early 20th century they would have carried out homicide attacks. Lol@ Somali youth shabaab are called youth they have support of many youth many tribal leaders , i am not sure about female soldiers what we do know is that the dervishes stoned woman to death , actually the Mad mullah fled at the battle of taleex when the tribal forces were closing in he fled and ran like a coward he left his wife and sisters naado buraale. Dervishes were maybe called saalixiya order. but they were salafi jihadist on all fronts. There is no much difference between shabaab and dervish just one was in the early 20th century and shabaab of the 21 century. But in their ideology they are the same.

[Tanker]

In the beginning of 1920, the British struck the Dervish settlements with a well-coordinated air and land attack and inflicted a stunning defeat. The forts of Hassan were damaged and his army suffered great losses. They hastily moved to Ogaden region to continue the Jihad. Here, again with the help of his patriotic poetry and charisma, he tried to rebuild his army and accomplish the coalition of Ogaden clans, which made him a power in the land once again.

[Tanker]

Khalid Ali

Yes they killed those who refused to support them or worked with the enemy any movement will do that in war and I support that

If I move towards somaliland controlled areas of sanaag with pro somalia forces then somaliland will kill me loool

did you expect the dervish to wait until they were all killed by the British airplanes ? lool

those who you call youth supporting shabab is just gangs and no tribal leaders just warlords lool

[samatar133]

Tankar
what is the diference between Ina Cabdille Xasan iyo Ina Cabdi Godane?
Do you also idolise Godane and his ALshabaab fighters?

You can not compare the dervish with al shabab its just silly, the dervish were sufi muslims who had many female fighters they were tolerant towards female rights, al shabab view females as animals, the dervish were supported by somali tribal leaders, somali youth, somali females, the al shabab is just a bunch of thugs and criminals from pakistan, arabia, somalia, they don't have any agenda or goal and they don't have support from somali muslim public they only know how to blow up civilians and flees from foreign troops like true cowards the dervish were lions who never ran away

you are one funny female. I don't know why do have to make up none existent history where Dervish movement was a feminist movement. Female rights iyo waxaasi is not ever relevant in what we are discussing, it is quite silly. Dervish were more criminal than Alshabaab because they were heavily involved in looting the poor somali people's livestock.
Though Alshabaab are as cruel as Derwish were, at least they have more dignity they don't steal from the poor nomadic people. When it comes to bravery Alshabaab took on Ethopia, Kenya, Uganda and America with their drone attacks while the so called Dervish fled in confusion in the first British air attack and their obese leader recited the famous calaacal poem,
Coomaadi duulay cadan ka keeneene------------ Caamir waa saleele haatan anaa caymadiye, Adiguba caqlaad leedehee carar maxaa dhaama
fulay fulay dhalay dheh, ma kaasay geesi ku sheegayaa?. Wali ma maqasheen Godane oo sidaa u calaacalaya, wale Amiirka argagaxisada ahi waa nin

[Tanker]

did you expect the dervish to wait until they were all killed by the British airplanes ?

they just moved to Somali Galbeed to continue the Jihad like real lions, the fact that the British superpower for the first time in the history of Africa were forced to use airplanes to bomb the dervish shows you how the british were not able to defeat the noble lions on the ground. They had to use airplanes like cowards the Dervish makes me proud to be Somali.

[Hawdian]

When is the book coming out? XPlaya if you need graphic designer for your cover page and illustrations let me know.

I do like to see my name somewhere in the historical book....

[grandpakhalif]

airstrikes were used on Sayid: the first in African history, of course they would fear such devastating new technology. Did you expect them to shoot the planes with their rifles?

[Marques]

Waraa khalidow ninyahow iska qabta yarkaan Kukri la yiraah..

Horta i dont know why Xplaya is getting grilled so much...he has a right to correct the misinformation that has been lingering in the Somali literature for decades...the dervish movement was sanctified by the former regime as some kind of glorious clan movement that set out to tame specific rival clans...which is far from the truth. Do you think Xplaya should back down and allow his adversaries to glare in his face with a piece of misused and tainted history? Now if Kukri is claiming why use British sources...didn't the kacaan linguists use the British sources themselves (though they heavily tampered with it and got state-backing for this, which is where the problem lies) since those sources are the only available primary evidence of the historical events at the time.