hargaysaay come in

[Siciid85]

No we are not related groups ancesterly wise for at least many years. Unless you are willing to go back as far as bariigi Nebi Adam alai salaam.
The fact you speak Somali, doesn't make you related to me (dhalaasho ahaan).

[SultanOrder]

Siciid, what about the other isaaqs like cumar labasuul, sahangalbeed, smatr who took the test and got E1b1, does that mean isaaq is a confederacy and sub clans like habar awal are more closer related to marexaan then garhajis?

[Siciid85]

Samatr Has T hablogroup much like Abdi. Ismail and the rest of the Garhajis who took the tests. Not sure about the others, the Isaaq is related
ancestry and marriage wise more than many ethnic Arab groups that have outliers within them. Marexaan is another case, we are neither
related ancestry wise or through centuries of intermarriage. So you are trying to compare apples and oranges.

[Thuganomics]

Waar eynu wax isku noqono iyo Diidney bey xaaladu mareysa imika miyaa

[Siciid85]

Thuganomics Thanks to DNA tests many myths were busted. I am going to visit Burkina Faso, Nigeria, Senegal to locate a Fulbe cutie.

So ancestry wise I am closer to this Fulani girl than a Marexan.

Rejoice.

[SultanOrder]

Samatr Has T hablogroup much like Abdi. Ismail and the rest of the Garhajis who took the tests. Not sure about the others, the Isaaq is related
ancestry and marriage wise more than many ethnic Arab groups that have outliers within them. Marexaan is another case, we are neither
related through ancestry or centuries of intermarriage. So you are trying to compare apples and oranges.

Why don't you just say we intermarry, considering you are saying those with different haplogroups are not descended from the same ancestry. I mean if you can make general statements of Habar yonis dna from one or two results, i can make the same general statements about the even more Habar awal that took the test and got e1b1. I conclude that isaaq are a confederation. But ofcourse related through proximity and marriage.

[Siciid85]

Not one or two, aside from Garhajis Sneters who took the tests all got T Hablogroup those outside Snet from Norway and Denmark who also
took the tests got T Hablogroup. It is not secret T Hablogroup is common among Somalilanders. I believe Darood is a confederation considering
some of you got different DNA results, there was this one Warsangeli guy who got J 1, some other DNA types while the rest got E1b1b but I couldn't
care less and would dismiss it as an outlier.


Now don't get butthurt that we are not related.

[SultanOrder]

To make my point I already conceded that the norm for Garhajis is J1, but I also maintain that the norm for Habar Awal Isaaq is E1b1. Therefore two subgroups of Isaaq got two different haplogroups, I therefore conclude that Isaaq is not related but a confederation.

[Siciid85]

J1? You mean T Hablogroup. It doesn't matter what you conclude, if one or two Habar Awal members got Jinni DNA I couldn't care less. They are part
of the Isaaq tribe. One of the most prominent elders of the Darood in the 20th century a Warsangli Sultan by the name Sultan Mohamud Cali Shire
was not even a Somali, but a man of an Indian father and a Somali mother. The Darood should be the last to talk about confederation.

[SultanOrder]

Siciid, only one or two (not speaking literally) garhajis took the dna test, so my conclusion is as valid as your conclusion.

[Siciid85]

Whether 10 GX or 100 took the test, what is clear is we are not related in anyway whether proximity, through intermarriages, ancestry. Live with those
hard facts.



I am out now, it is enough bulldozing for the day. Always remember a Fulani is closer to me than a Marexan before you start claiming
our sub clans of Reer Mataan, Maxamed Daud etc. Have a good day.

[SultanOrder]

No problem siciid, lakin Marexaan and Habar awal are more closely related to eachother than H.A and Garhajis. No wonder Emperior is so partial to us, ileen we are qaraabo

[Siciid85]

Your people can have Emperior/Khalid Ali.

[Eaglehawk]

what is this loser saciid on about
this thread was about hargeesay a person he was taunting and now he is sucking up to him like habar maseertay
saciid take your uqdad and pathetic nacnac out of here

perfect order can ha la dood uqdad ba ku riday you don`t know how I play with his mind

adali
why you on my case nigga?

hargeyseey you are always welcome among sade people don`t make yourself a stranger in the gedo section

[Siciid85]

I couldn't care less about Hargaysaay he is an individual, just don't claim Garhajis sub clans you sad cunt, we don't even share the same DNA ancestry. Isn't
your Cayr pimps enough for you? You 2 dollar h8es, hal nin ku ekaada.