Which is worse?

[greenday]

Do you know that when you go to hajj you cant enter with only one sin, which is murder. you cant take it in to be forgiven.

[Cinque Mtume]

Do you know that when you go to hajj you cant enter with only one sin, which is murder. you cant take it in to be forgiven.

I didn't know that. All I knew was that you're not allowed to go to Hajj while you still owe money to people.

[greenday]

Do you know that when you go to hajj you cant enter with only one sin, which is murder. you cant take it in to be forgiven.

I didn't know that. All I knew was that you're not allowed to go to Hajj while you still owe money to people.

It doesn't mean you cant go it means that there is no chance that the sin will be forgiven, you enter without this sin i heard and that as soon as you leave waa laguso celinaa.

[Cinque Mtume]

I see. That makes sense now I think about it. I guess a sin like murder is left for the judgement of Allah in akhiro.

[union]

Shirk.

[Beenaale_No1]

Do you know that when you go to hajj you cant enter with only one sin, which is murder. you cant take it in to be forgiven.

I didn't know that. All I knew was that you're not allowed to go to Hajj while you still owe money to people.

It doesn't mean you cant go it means that there is no chance that the sin will be forgiven, you enter without this sin i heard and that as soon as you leave waa laguso celinaa.

Arinta hadey sidas tahay, look at the thousands of Muslims who have been killed by fellow Muslims in conflicts in North Africa + Middle East in recent months. Kuwan aakhira xagey tegaayaan.

Some people just find murder so easy to commit.

[Cinque Mtume]

Arinta hadey sidas tahay, look at the thousands of Muslims who have been killed by fellow Muslims in conflicts in North Africa + Middle East in recent months. Kuwan aakhira xagey tegaayaan.

Only Allah knows.

[greenday]

Beenaale that's why just being Muslim doesn't mean you end up in Janna.

[Nabeela]

I heard if you kill once, it's easier for you to do it the 2nd, 3rd time, and forth.

[NoAngst]

What is a murderer doing at Hajj in the first place? Shouldn't he/she be in prison?

Call me old fashioned but I prefer criminals put of out commission, rotting in decripit prison cell where they can rue lost liberties and suffer the indignities of dehumanizing prison life.

[Cinque Mtume]

Beenaale that's why just being Muslim doesn't mean you end up in Janna.

greenday, I think you misunderstood. Murder cannot be forgiven by mere Hajj or other good acts. But it can be forgiven and you could still go to Jano even if you've killed 40 people.

Otherwise you might as well live a hedonistic lifestyle after committing a murder. You're going to burn in hell anyway.

[Maandhow]

I am really suprised how people attempting to respond certain question.
dont try to answer it if you are not qualified scholar, which sins are forgiveable and which sins are not forgiveable depends on the circumstance
you may kill someone while your asleep in this case your innocent . However, certain question you need to have expert knowledge in that field to go into details before you say this is haram and shirk

[greenday]

Beenaale that's why just being Muslim doesn't mean you end up in Janna.

greenday, I think you misunderstood. Murder cannot be forgiven by mere Hajj or other good acts. But it can be forgiven and you could still go to Jano even if you've killed 40 people.

Otherwise you might as well live a hedonistic lifestyle after committing a murder. You're going to burn in hell anyway.

I was just being general here about committing sins and being a Muslim. Am not sure about who can forgive you for murder since the person is dead Or if you get killed it cancels out, but it gets even more confusing because all life belongs to Allah so maybe you don't need the forgiveness of the individual and Allah can just forgive you on his own Ani moogi runta hada iska sheego.

[NoAngst]

Maandheey,

Actually it is entirely upto Allah which sins are forgiveable and which aren't. You can be the most squeaky clean Muslim in the world and Allah can still condemn you to eternal hellfire. That's the privilege of being Allah. Allah can do whatever He wants.

[SultanOrder]