shocking news about islam these days.

[Goljano Lion]

dude i read the whole article, and you don't proof me wrong, it is the scholars who said that women cannot lead prayers. dude this scholars said this and that is not proof and when it comes to Muslim scholars opinions , we all know they have difference of opinion and disagreement about every thing

There's no Muslim scholar (who lives in a Muslim country) who has the opinion that a woman can lead mixed-gender prayers. I challenge you to find such a scholar. Besides, women never led mixed-gender prayers during the era of the prophet (salalaahu calayhi wasalam), Sahaba and the generations who followed them.

is there any Hadith or a verse which prohibits women leading prayers? the answer is no
sxb it has to do with culture, don't you know in Saudi Arabia, it is illegal for women to drive cars

[AbuShabab]

is there any Hadith or a verse which prohibits women leading prayers? the answer is no
sxb it has to do with culture, don't you know in Saudi Arabia, it is illegal for women to drive cars

You want me to do your homework by reading for you the link I provided? You obviously didn't read the link. So, you want a Hadith or a verse for everything? You want a Hadith or a verse that let's you know if you can drive a bike, car, airplane, etc? You want a Hadith or a verse that lets you know if you can have a Lasik operation or hair transplant (if you're bald)? Is that your understanding of Islam? It's either there's a Hadith/verse that won't let you do it or you do it?

[Goljano Lion]

is there any Hadith or a verse which prohibits women leading prayers? the answer is no
sxb it has to do with culture, don't you know in Saudi Arabia, it is illegal for women to drive cars

You want me to do your homework by reading for you the link I provided? You obviously didn't read the link. So, you want a Hadith or a verse for everything? You want a Hadith or a verse that let's you know if you can drive a bike, car, airplane, etc? You want a Hadith or a verse that lets you know if you can have a Lasik operation or hairs transplant (if you're bald)? Is that your understanding of Islam? It's either there's a Hadith/verse that won't let you do it or you do it?

waryaa sxb bring me proof ,concrete proof, i am not convince yet, where is sheikh Hyber WHEN YOU NEED HIM

[AbuShabab]

waryaa sxb bring me proof ,concrete proof, i am not convince yet, where is sheikh Hyber WHEN YOU NEED HIM

There's proof in the link I gave you. It's upto you to read it.

[+chilli]

TrophY-WifeY- sis dogs arent allowed in mosques whether the person is blind or not!! the fact that he was blind made it not compulsory for him to go. you now how men have to have to go to mosques for prayer? well not the ill, disabled and un-able ones. they dont have to go. anyways what he did was not right, in a sence you cannot correct you deeds but commiting a sin. thats just stupid. how is a sin going to give you ajar if what you doing is wrong to start with?

????. Its a sin to take a dog into the masjid out of neccesity?

Abu, giving him a link especially Q&A is not prove. Let me make it easy, GL there is no hadith that states likewise, reason why this debate existences.
Btw Abu this debate was first trigged in Egypt.

[AbuShabab]

Abu, giving him a link especially Q&A is not prove. Let me make it easy, GL there is no hadith that states likewise, reason why this debate existences.
Btw Abu this debate was first trigged in Egypt.

I understand you agree with Amina Wadud leading mixed-gender prayers.

[+chilli]

No, I am following the debate.

[surrender]

TrophY-WifeY- sis dogs arent allowed in mosques whether the person is blind or not!! the fact that he was blind made it not compulsory for him to go. you now how men have to have to go to mosques for prayer? well not the ill, disabled and un-able ones. they dont have to go. anyways what he did was not right, in a sence you cannot correct you deeds but commiting a sin. thats just stupid. how is a sin going to give you ajar if what you doing is wrong to start with?

????. Its a sin to take a dog into the masjid out of neccesity?

yes. seen as they not allowed in our homes, is only correct that they are not allowed in holy places either.

[AbuShabab]

No, I am following the debate.

It's positive that you reject Amina Wadud's bidcah.