SomaliNet Forums

Imam HutuKing,

Never mind these mislead Jabertis. Do not allow them to drag you to their level. Lets see them supporting chopping off limbs in their cities: Las Canood & Balanbale. They will not fund or support such actions because of their primary loyalty to Jabeertism over any applicable Sharica law.

correction: this wasn't islamic punishment - though i've nothing against executing pedos - the yemeni law is secular and jahiliyya.


so i don't see what islam has to do with this thread?

Somali-Star wrote:executing pedos

Not just a pedo, but a pedo who killed the boy and cut him up for easy disposal. Yet some people are oblivious to this because of tribal politics in Somalia.

Inaa Lilaahu Wa Inaa ileehi Raajicuun

A/W, walaal waan kuu baqayaa inaad bed qabto iyo inkale..

How were you able to twist this topic about the punishment of a pedophile/killer who raped an 11 yr old into Qabiil? La Xawla Wala Quwati, Ilaa Bilaahi Caliyi Cadiim

Ismahan123 wrote:Hoogay! warn ppl 1st waxyahow walan.

iljeexda waalan,,always read the title before u click,,it says shocking picture

If it’s true what the guy is accused of then he deserves the punishment. Let’s hope he had fair trail and he was convicted beyond reasonable doubt.

Diyeeshaha_Tolka wrote:wiil yar ayuu kufsaday kadibna dilay,,

They are being too kind to him. They should burn sick child molesters alive.

Fuck that shit, that's not my religion.

quote"nomadicwarlord"Fuck that shit, that's not my religion.


Which religion?

The religion that persecuted the man who raped and killed an 11 yrs old kid or the religion that is denouncing the execution of the pedo/killer?

nomadicwarlord wrote:Fuck that shit, that's not my religion.

What is wrong with you? the guy raped and killed an 11 year old boy, and your saying him being killed is injustice? WTF.

They should have stoned him to an agonizing death in my opinion.

Horta why don't they stone to death people like this? They are more deserving than that girl in Kismayo

nomadicwarlord wrote:Fuck that shit, that's not my religion.

True,public punishments is not part of our religion, of REAL ISLAM. i still have not seen 1 clear verse from quran.

Muhammad bin Harti wrote:

nomadicwarlord wrote:Fuck that shit, that's not my religion.

What is wrong with you? the guy raped and killed an 11 year old boy, and your saying him being killed is injustice? WTF.

They should have stoned him to an agonizing death in my opinion.

Probably misunderstood what I said. I didn't defend that rapist, justice should def be served for what he did. I was tryin to say that kind of punishment is not part of my religion. They should have done it other ways. Death shouldn't be a spectacle event. That's just my opinion.

This is barbaric but expected from the religion of peace and tolerance.

A number of appalling rationalization were made by some craven critters on SNet. I say craven critters because these people prefer justice served by liberal democracies (by living in liberal democracies) and yet support barbaric and inhumane punishments served by theocratic dictatorships or vigilante justice. Stop hiding in the West and go live under the justice systems you support.

With that said, here are a couple of appalling rationalizations:

1) Barbaric public punishments are about deterrence.

ANS: there are two problems with this argument. One, where is JUSTICE? Deterrence and justice are not the same. Where is the justice of the victim and the accused Did the little kid who was allegedly raped and then dismembered not deserve justice? Second, if these public punishments are about deterrence, why do they have to be so barbaric? We protect against car theft with car insurance, theft protection systems, cameras in parking lots and so on. There are so many non-violent measures we can take to deter against potential crimes, why do the punishment have to be so gruesome and bloody?

2) These punishments are needed to fight crime

ANS: If gruesome public punishment are such a good tool against crimes, why did Europeans, who by all objective measures used as gruesome if not more gruesome public punishments less than 200 hundred years ago, stopped using those punishments? It is interesting question don't you think? Give it a thought or do some research as to why Europeans ended these practices but muslims practice 'em in 2009. Just to give a hint: it's not secular Islamic governments with strong judicial systems that practice these punishments; it's mostly practiced in countries with weak states or where no functioning state exists plus states ideologically committed to implementing medieval punishments (Iran and S. Arabia for instance).