Matching SomaliNet's DNA research to Hallenberg 2005 Study

[James Dahl]

James
Isse Raghe. His DYS439 = 12 Not 11.

Ah thank you Abdihaliim, that was my mistake

[grandpakhalif]

James is it possible for a Somali to get J1?

[James Dahl]

James is it possible for a Somali to get J1?

I don't see why not, especially Reer Xamar.

[Oxidant]

James is it possible for a Somali to get J1?

I don't see why not, especially Reer Xamar.

They are not ethnic Somalis. I think he was more referring those from the major tribes

[James Dahl]

James is it possible for a Somali to get J1?

I don't see why not, especially Reer Xamar.

They are not ethnic Somalis. I think he was more referring those from the major tribes

Well there's several ways, your clan could "become" part of a bigger clan, or you could have what genealogists call a "non-parental event" in your ancestry, which is a fancy word for incorrect paternity.

If the whole branch of your clan is J1, then it's probably the former, and if it's just your branch of that clan, it's probably the latter.

[James Dahl]

I added in some results from other studies like Immel 2009 and Tillman 2009.

[IRONm@N]

Good job james.
do you have Abdirahman and Mohamud's contact info, as it seems that we are 100% match?
thanks for details, its more clear.

[James Dahl]

Good job james.
do you have Abdirahman and Mohamud's contact info, as it seems that we are 100% match?
thanks for details, its more clear.

Yeah there's a contact link on their ysearch.org profiles:
http://www.ysearch.org/search_view.asp? ... =GPWCC&p=0#
http://www.ysearch.org/search_view.asp? ... =8MH8T&p=0

It pops up a message box where you can send them a message.

[James Dahl]

If anyone would like to anonymously contact me in regards to any results they have received, please do so

[Oxidant]

WTF,

Italian who is E1b1b1a1b how is that possible?

What do the numbers on the side mean? If they are the same, does it mean same ancestry

[James Dahl]

WTF,

Italian who is E1b1b1a1b how is that possible?

What do the numbers on the side mean? If they are the same, does it mean same ancestry

E1b1b1a1b is 8,500 years old, plenty of time for some African fellow to end up in Sicily somehow.
Sicily was once conquered by the Caliphate, perhaps some soldier originally from Sudan or southern Egypt decided to settle there.

[Cinque Mtume]

WTF,

Italian who is E1b1b1a1b how is that possible?

What do the numbers on the side mean? If they are the same, does it mean same ancestry

E1b1b1a1b is 8,500 years old, plenty of time for some African fellow to end up in Sicily somehow.
Sicily was once conquered by the Caliphate, perhaps some soldier originally from Sudan or southern Egypt decided to settle there.

James Dahl,


I had my results a while back too. The most interesting thing is that I'm the most closely related in that bunch to Hyperactive. Our markers are the exact same, while the Hartis are a little more different from me. I'm Majerten btw.

[Real_Talk]

James is it possible for a Somali to get J1?

LOL

you really wanna be descendant from some arab right?

[Ganjaweed]

WTF,

Italian who is E1b1b1a1b how is that possible?

What do the numbers on the side mean? If they are the same, does it mean same ancestry

E1b1b1a1b is 8,500 years old, plenty of time for some African fellow to end up in Sicily somehow.
Sicily was once conquered by the Caliphate, perhaps some soldier originally from Sudan or southern Egypt decided to settle there.

James Dahl,


I had my results a while back too. The most interesting thing is that I'm the most closely related in that bunch to Hyperactive. Our markers are the exact same, while the Hartis are a little more different from me. I'm Majerten btw.

Sneaky bastard, you where waiting on everyone else before you disclosed your results weren't you. Just in case you were the only one with E3b .

[Cinque Mtume]

E1b1b1a1b is 8,500 years old, plenty of time for some African fellow to end up in Sicily somehow.
Sicily was once conquered by the Caliphate, perhaps some soldier originally from Sudan or southern Egypt decided to settle there.

James Dahl,


I had my results a while back too. The most interesting thing is that I'm the most closely related in that bunch to Hyperactive. Our markers are the exact same, while the Hartis are a little more different from me. I'm Majerten btw.

Sneaky bastard, you where waiting on everyone else before you disclosed your results weren't you. Just in case you were the only one with E3b .

I thought you left this place bro.

Drop me a line in the PM box man, we need to talk serious stuff.