Page 1 of 2
Hodan and Elmi Did not exist
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 5:53 pm
by Minneapolis Mayor
“Intaan adiga kugu gooni ahaa - geed hadaan la hadlo.
Ama aan gawaan qodayo - may gama'sanaateene
Gaaladu ha joogtee sidaa - kaaga go'i waayey?
Sidii aad go'aygii tahiyo - macamus aan goostay
Ama aad godkii aakhiro - geeri iga baajin
Ama aan gayiga lagu ogayn - gabadh kaloo joogta
Gar-darniyaa maxaan Hodan Cabdiyeey - kaaga go'i waayey?
Gadiidkii aan toosaba - adaan kuu guntanayaaye
Goobtaan istaagaba dhulkaan - godad ka jeexaaye
Sidii aad gidaar tahay - maxaa kaa igarab taagay?
Gar-darniyaa maxaan Hodan Cabdiyeey - kaaga go'i waayey?
Mana goosan kari waayin oo - geesi baan ahaye
Adaan kaa gun-gaadhaayey oo - helay guntaadiiye
Gar-darniyaa maxaan Hodan Cabdiyeey - kaaga go'i waayey?
This Elmi boodhari did not exist or fall in Love.
Re: Hodan and Elmi Did not exist
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 6:02 pm
by Meyle
Cilmi Boodheri didnt exists? He was the relative of my grandmother for god's sake. Niyow waxaad ku hadleysid ma wanaagsanee iska aamus. Waad calaacaleysaa 24/7. Nafyahey guuldarado heysato iskaga tag Somalinet, kuuma wanaagsanee.
Re: Hodan and Elmi Did not exist
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 6:10 pm
by Bro

They did exist, he was reer berbera If I'm not mistaken.
Re: Hodan and Elmi Did not exist
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 6:22 pm
by Meyle

They did exist, he was reer berbera If I'm not mistaken.
He was not originally from Berbera but moved there, it was the capital of British Somaliland during those years.
Re: Hodan and Elmi Did not exist
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 6:24 pm
by Minneapolis Mayor
Cilmi Boodhari was a fiction story just like Qays and Leyla.
Re: Hodan and Elmi Did not exist
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 6:27 pm
by Meyle
Cilmi Boodhari was a fiction story just like Qays and Leyla.
Explain to me how he was fiction! War bal mucjisadan ila eega, you need to take your pills and masturbate to your fictive wives/girlfriends.
Re: Hodan and Elmi Did not exist
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 6:53 pm
by AgentOfChaos
So this fucker is saying Cilmi Ismaaciil Liibaan didn't exist?! This is some fucked up shit right there.
Re: Hodan and Elmi Did not exist
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 6:55 pm
by FarIyoAlif

elaborate..........
Re: Hodan and Elmi Did not exist
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 7:52 pm
by Minneapolis Mayor
Guys,
Some abwaan wanted to form gabay and he chose a fiction character name Elmi boodhari after his Friend Elmi Liibaan.
Re: Hodan and Elmi Did not exist
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 7:58 pm
by X.Playa
Thats his sister (from 33 minutes ..) still living... do you think the story took place 200 years ago loo, cilmi died in the 1930's
Re: Hodan and Elmi Did not exist
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 9:17 pm
by DR-YALAXOOW
yes Elmi boodhari story is a fabricated one... Yes a man called Elmi nicnamed boodhari existed. and elmi boodhari use to work bread factory in berbera.. and year after he died a natural causes, this love story of elmi died because of jaceeyl of hodan surfaced.. so probably the story is just fictional....
there are many stories which was exaggerated for example sayid mohamed abdula hassan is exaggerated and hes status of a somali hero is a fictional. and all poems which said sayid maxamed abdulle hassans gabays is made up 50 years after hes death...
and wiil waal never existed as cigaal shidaad never existed.. so there are many made up stories through out history...
Re: Hodan and Elmi Did not exist
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 9:23 pm
by IRONm@N
yes Elmi boodhari story is a fabricated one... Yes a man called Elmi nicnamed boodhari existed. and elmi boodhari use to work bread factory in berbera.. and year after he died a natural causes, this love story of elmi died because of jaceeyl of hodan surfaced.. so probably the story is just fictional....
there are many stories which was exaggerated for example sayid mohamed abdula hassan is exaggerated and hes status of a somali hero is a fictional. and all poems which said sayid maxamed abdulle hassans gabays is made up 50 years after hes death...
and wiil waal never existed as cigaal shidaad never existed.. so there are many made up stories though out history...
History revisionist. so basically you saying if you don't have a video or a picture of them, they all fictional. so what is next?
ahmed Gurey and Olol Diinle didn't exist
Re: Hodan and Elmi Did not exist
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 9:26 pm
by Tanker
yes Elmi boodhari story is a fabricated one... Yes a man called Elmi nicnamed boodhari existed. and elmi boodhari use to work bread factory in berbera.. and year after he died a natural causes, this love story of elmi died because of jaceeyl of hodan surfaced.. so probably the story is just fictional....
there are many stories which was exaggerated for example sayid mohamed abdula hassan is exaggerated and hes status of a somali hero is a fictional. and all poems which said sayid maxamed abdulle hassans gabays is made up 50 years after hes death...
and wiil waal never existed as cigaal shidaad never existed.. so there are many made up stories through out history...

Nolow DR Yalaxoow
Re: Hodan and Elmi Did not exist
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 9:28 pm
by zulaika
has there ever been a version of this story told through Hodan's perspective? did she feel the same way?
Re: Hodan and Elmi Did not exist
Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2013 9:34 pm
by DR-YALAXOOW
History revisionist. so basically you saying if you don't have a video or a picture of them, they all fictional. so what is next?
ahmed Gurey and Olol Diinle didn't exist
Listen my friend for example maxamed abdulle hassan as historical person did existed. but the status of being hero and gabyaa and geat somali leader is fabricated one. for example houndred of allegged sayid maxamed abdulle xassan poems surfaced when siyaad bare become president whit out any evidance existance manuscribts of such gabayo existed.
its like todays ABUU MANSUUR( al shabaab eelaay) year 2113 people of baydhabo make up story of Abuu mansuur al eelaay who lived 1968 to 2020 was great hero who fought against world and he was great gabygaaa. and people of baydhaboland in 2113 will believe such story 100% because they was not here when abuu mansuur was alive..
marka sxb its easy to make up story when all people who lived that persons life time do not live anymore....