Page 3 of 3
Re: Are Somalis Ethiopian?
Posted: Mon Feb 02, 2015 1:03 am
by TheMailMan
Are all of the Horn is related some how 10.000 Years ago Estrix not all Somalis have tested somalis share the exact same haplogroups with other ethnic groups in the HORN , ethiopia is a country with many ethnic groups not all ethnic groups have same relations and there are Somalis in Ethiopia , Ethiopia predates the Somali republic ,Somaalis were called Somaalis for a long period of time. But the first writing of the name Somaali was first seen in a Poem recited by Habashi King which is very funny lol the ogaden professor who wrote about allot of the Somali genealogies wrote about it.
Yes, if you go back far enough we have common origins, but majority of somalis males share y dna subclade and if you do a full autosmal test somalis nearly have identical admixture levels, you see despite having common origins (proto ea) we have branched off and through the thousands of years of movement we ended up adapting to our environment (genes) and also receiving admixture from other groups in the horn (or close) such as omotic and euroasians.
Exactly, Somalis are a distinct ethnic group that share common origins, and share genetic similarities as well as historical similarities.
We are Somalis
Re: Are Somalis Ethiopian?
Posted: Mon Feb 02, 2015 1:52 am
by MrSalih
Platinum, Ethiopia is a multi ethnic state. Anyone one that resides there is Ethiopian irrespective of ethnicity. You should have asked, what are the origins of the Somali people? That is hard to answer because the Somali identity is more than a millennium old and we do not all share a common ancestry, a paternal one anyway.
We are linguistically closely related to some ethnic groups in Ethiopia and
Sudan
. We even share some cultural traits.
No Pun bro,but excluding the beja in the east where's the relation?Explain yourself.
Signed Salih.....
Re: Are Somalis Ethiopian?
Posted: Mon Feb 02, 2015 2:08 am
by PLATINUUM
Platinum, Ethiopia is a multi ethnic state. Anyone one that resides there is Ethiopian irrespective of ethnicity. You should have asked, what are the origins of the Somali people? That is hard to answer because the Somali identity is more than a millennium old and we do not all share a common ancestry, a paternal one anyway.
We are linguistically closely related to some ethnic groups in Ethiopia and
Sudan
. We even share some cultural traits.
No Pun bro,but excluding the beja in the east where's the relation?Explain yourself.
Signed Salih.....
Re: Are Somalis Ethiopian?
Posted: Mon Feb 02, 2015 2:08 am
by PLATINUUM
Thank you all for your responses i learned a lot!