Postby Sir-Luggoyo » Wed Jan 25, 2006 4:54 pm
[quote="generalka"]
Also, about the deal of cutting ones hand off when they steal. I really dont like that ruling too; what if the person was stealing to live? Will you starve the poor guy and on top of it cut his hands off? I support that but only if the person stole expensive things for the purpose of making a profit.[/quote]
Generale,
During the time of Khalif Cumar Ibn-Al-Khataab (RA), a young man was caught stealing and brought to him to sever his hand, despite the Islamic treasury making sure that no one goes hungry, this kid resorted to stealing. His mother showed up at the court and started pleading for her son and asked Cumar (RA) to spare her son and added that it is his first time to steal. Omar asked the son how many times he stole prior to this time, and he made swore in Allah's name when answering that question. The man said, since I don't want to utter Allah's name in vain, I will tell the truth, he said this is his 16th time he stole something. Omar (RA) said, if it was his first time Allah would've saved him, and that is when his hand was cut off.
Implementing Sharia is not an easy matter, you have to satisfy the needs of the populace, second, you have to exhaust every other means, you have to prove the guilty party beyong any shadow of doubt, even if they are habitual and pathological individuals.