We shouldnt abuse the idea, because it is something many of our Phrophets (pbuh) did!
But ideally.. Hell No!

Just the thought creeps me out. To me it is beyond something I could even imagen. Maybe because my mother and father have been loyal to one another ever since they were young and got married thier love is still blossoming Alxamduilaah. So coming from that.. I dont even know anyone who has done this sort of thing.
To be fare, the man has got to be God Fearing 100%, a true believer and stable in his deen if it is going to work. The two women (or more) should be self aware and secure about themselves, not insecure and have low self esteem if it is to work. Otherwise, theres problems on each direction

!!
Maybe Im just selfish. But remember, at the end of the day.. Marriage and having children is primarily (as well as other things, i.e love, companionship) is to 'produce' the future ummah, raise children under the name of Islam and as Allah's slaves.

..
There will come a day when there will be more women than men. So men will result to marrying more than one women, the day of recurreation will come when one man is to share 8 women.. Subxanallah!!