Is it good or bad for Somalia

[hanad_mn]

Ok Puntland are threatening to Declare themselves another country, How big of a blow would it be to somalia hadii Puntland goosato?

So many Northern Somalia tribes left and We didn't care shit about it

[AhlulbaytSoldier]

Iam hoping for this day to come.

[Crazy Cat Lady]

^ It would be the death knell for Somaliland's hopes for recognition, so yes it would be a good thing

[GENERAL_SNM]

Puntland folks are only bluffing they haven't got the guts or stomach to do a somaliland.

[gurey25]

^ It would be the death knell for Somaliland's hopes for recognition, so yes it would be a good thing

really thats an unusual line of thinking?
How ? please explain?

[marcassmith]

Puntland demands to leave the union should be respected. Their self-determination needs to be fulfilled.

The fragmentation of Somalia is not necessary a bad thing. We will have trade and diplomatic ties.

God Bless

[Ureysoo]

Somalia will turn 2 a body without a HEAD, if Puntland took few steps towards sovereignty...

[Crazy Cat Lady]

^ It would be the death knell for Somaliland's hopes for recognition, so yes it would be a good thing

really thats an unusual line of thinking?
How ? please explain?

It would be a brilliant example for the international community of the effects of accepting secession, the wanton fragmentation of a nation, which will set a dangerous precedent for the world.

[gurey25]

^ It would be the death knell for Somaliland's hopes for recognition, so yes it would be a good thing

really thats an unusual line of thinking?
How ? please explain?

It would be a brilliant example for the international community of the effects of accepting secession, the wanton fragmentation of a nation, which will set a dangerous precedent for the world.

What does that have anything to do with somaliland,
we are already in that situation, nothing can make it worse.

it may even be a good thing, puntland is one of the many causes of chaos and disunity in the south, removing ountland means less people fighting for the throne
meaning faster resolusion.

[ModerateMuslim]

Ok Puntland are threatening to Declare themselves another country, How big of a blow would it be...

it'd be a big blow to ethiopia if puntland freed itself from enslavement to ethiopia

[Crazy Cat Lady]

What does that have anything to do with somaliland,
we are already in that situation, nothing can make it worse.

Secession has everything to do with Somaliland

it may even be a good thing, puntland is one of the many causes of chaos and disunity in the south, removing ountland means less people fighting for the throne meaning faster resolusion.

By removing Puntland, there will be greater unity in the South? Interesting. Do you know what a 'contradiction' is?

[GENERAL_SNM]

These people assume that puntland is some sort of defensive linebacker stopping Somaliland bolting out the door. They say ''misery needs company'' and thats the only logical explanation...

[gurey25]

What does that have anything to do with somaliland,
we are already in that situation, nothing can make it worse.

Secession has everything to do with Somaliland

it may even be a good thing, puntland is one of the many causes of chaos and disunity in the south, removing ountland means less people fighting for the throne meaning faster resolusion.

By removing Puntland, there will be greater unity in the South? Interesting. Do you know what a 'contradiction' is?

oh i keep forgetting, you are one of those people who actually believe that we havent seceded yet,
and that there is a chance that we would be part of another union with the south.


about the last statement, there is no contradiction, remove puntland less problems in the south..
this is self evident and intuitive, i think most people will be thinking the same..

[Ureysoo]

Ok Puntland are threatening to Declare themselves another country, How big of a blow would it be...

it'd be a big blow to ethiopia if puntland freed itself from enslavement to ethiopia

Lol, This must be the only objective ONLF = "One-Naag’s-Liberation-Front" or should I say Cagdheers have in mind. Yet, failed miserably to achieve hitherto.....

[Crazy Cat Lady]

What does that have anything to do with somaliland,
we are already in that situation, nothing can make it worse.

Secession has everything to do with Somaliland

it may even be a good thing, puntland is one of the many causes of chaos and disunity in the south, removing ountland means less people fighting for the throne meaning faster resolusion.

By removing Puntland, there will be greater unity in the South? Interesting. Do you know what a 'contradiction' is?

oh i keep forgetting, you are one of those people who actually believe that we havent seceded yet,
and that there is a chance that we would be part of another union with the south.


about the last statement, there is no contradiction, remove puntland less problems in the south..
this is self evident and intuitive, i think most people will be thinking the same..

You have seceded, but you haven't been recognised as a state, and inshallah you never will. Puntland is a shining beacon for the south, removing it would be a friggin disaster for the South.