I Support Benadir State

[Murax]

If what is being rumored is true about some advocating with making some districts of Xamar a Federal District and the other part of Benadir then I say do it.


Jubbaland/Puntland/Benadir State, etc.

[Osob101]

Why the sudden change and that would mean your Jubbaland would have a border with Ex-Benadir state which means the backward, Bantu, Moryaan, Hutu etc etc Hawiye will be your neighbors

[Murax]

Why the sudden change and that would mean your Jubbaland would have a border with Ex-Benadir state which means the backward, Bantu, Moryaan, Hutu etc etc Hawiye will be your neighbors

Why are You talking like I'm some Dayuus. Xamar whether its Federal or not, will always have a clear majority which is Hawiye, so what difference will it make whether it is Federal or not? Bottom line is it might as well be. The question is what would be the 2nd region to form the state with Benadir? Looks like Hiiraan is being forced into the Central State, and L Shabelle seems to be shaping out to become a major headache. I'm assuming Middle Shabelle?

[Osob101]

The Plan has always been the a Banaadir state that will include the two Shabeele and Xamar. Mirifle have no say in this and Digil have more in common with me as a Mudulood be it history, customs etc etc than having with Mirifle. Just wait for the planned Conference in none other than Merca

[Murax]

The Plan has always been the a Banaadir state that will include the two Shabeele and Xamar. Mirifle have no say in this and Digil have more in common with me as a Mudulood be it history, customs etc etc than having with Mirifle. Just wait for the planned Conference in none other than Merca

no problem if that happens, I as a Marehan/Darood I have no dog in this potential Hawiye/D&M L Shabelle conflict. Hopefully it resolves itself.

[Osob101]

As a Darood off course you have a dog in this fiasco. We don't have to sugar coat it

[Murax]

As a Darood off course you have a dog in this fiasco. We don't have to sugar coat it

lol, I really don't. Besides Mudulood/Sade are best of friends

[500ml]

Federalism wont work for our nation.

[The`Republic]

Osob-

I am genuinely curious. Except for the Wacdaan in Afgooye who are more Digil than Mudulood in culture, what is Mudulood about Lower Shabelle? You aren't even a military and political power there and Hawiye is really represented by the Habar Gidir.

I doubt Digil and Mirifle are going to allow divide and conquer today and as a cultural unit and shared dialect they can't evn be separated.

I think the possibility of a Benadir State with Lower Shabelle is less likely than the pipe dream of 6-regions.

[original dervish]

S Hoose will be part of SW state........definitely.

[Zizzz]

I think the possibility of a Benadir State with Lower Shabelle is less likely than the pipe dream of 6-regions.

C'mon now waryaa, are you seriously deluding yourself Balcad, Qoryooleey and Marka will be governed by Baydhabo? War jiraaba cakaaruhuu imaan.

[HusseinHassan]

S Hoose will be part of SW state........definitely.

what jubbaland needs to do is, help our southwest state neighbors build their state, consisting of bay, bakool and lower shabeele.

[original dervish]

They don't need any help......they've dealt with moryaan thugs in the past.....and will do so in the future.

[BigBreak]

see whenever any discussion on federalism is mentioned, always it includes clan. such a toxic mix

[Osob101]

Osob-

I am genuinely curious. Except for the Wacdaan in Afgooye who are more Digil than Mudulood in culture, what is Mudulood about Lower Shabelle? You aren't even a military and political power there and Hawiye is really represented by the Habar Gidir.

I doubt Digil and Mirifle are going to allow divide and conquer today and as a cultural unit and shared dialect they can't evn be separated.

I think the possibility of a Benadir State with Lower Shabelle is less likely than the pipe dream of 6-regions.

What do you know about Lower Shabelle other than what you read on the internet. Forget Abgaal, a whole sub clan of my Daud Lineage are exclusively found in shabeele Hoose. Wacdaan, Mobleen, Hilibi Darandoole are exclusively Shabeele Hoose clans. Digil does not even share an Birth Lineage with Mirifle let alone customs. There is more chance of Jubba Dhexe being ripped off since Darood do not constitute the majority than Shabeele Hoose ever coming under anything outside of Ex-Banaadir. Darood can try as much as they want but in a Million years will you have 2 Federal state and me one. If you have 2 than I must have 3 and if you have 3 than I will make sure I have 4.