Moderator: Moderators
You can believe whatever you want sxb, criticize SL and even oppose SL but why do you regurgitate the rhetoric and propaganda of our enemies? The term secession doesnt apply to SL, its something our enemies made up to delegitimize SL.Sxb ii waran horta. Where have you been hiding? Each to their own I say. Why do I need to have same views as you or any other secessionist? Does that make you feel less secure?
I am Isxaaq and I'm believer in the greater goal not this failed project that feeds only few handful thugs.
Firstly, Somaliland is unilaterally succeeding from Somalia since it does not have the legitimacy to dissolve the union.You can believe whatever you want sxb, criticize SL and even oppose SL but why do you regurgitate the rhetoric and propaganda of our enemies? The term secession doesnt apply to SL, its something our enemies made up to delegitimize SL.Sxb ii waran horta. Where have you been hiding? Each to their own I say. Why do I need to have same views as you or any other secessionist? Does that make you feel less secure?
I am Isxaaq and I'm believer in the greater goal not this failed project that feeds only few handful thugs.
We know that Dofaar Ismaciil and Hutus have committed unprecedented acts of treachery since 1890, when they together with their fascist Italian master waged war against the legitimate rulers of southern Zoomalia. The idea that Dofaar and Hutu own the destiny of all Somalis stems from this era hence their duopoly politics. Even the notion of Somaliweyn (La Grande Somalia) was coined by their fascist father Mussolini.
Two mongrel clans that invited foreign troops to Somali soil, allowed nuclear waste to be dumped in coastal areas and even worse than that, raped, murdered and starved interriverine communities for personal gains, are now calling for "genuine" 'Somali unity' and 'Somali nationalism'. Do you really believe that?
We know these animals very well and their malign nature. Theres nothing honest about their crocodile tears.
There are some things I dont like about SL and its politics but I will always support my country. I believe Somalilanders should be more honest and allow constructive criticism.
The word is secede. You do not secede from a union, you dissolve it.Firstly, Somaliland is unilaterally succeeding from Somalia since it does not have the legitimacy to dissolve the union.You can believe whatever you want sxb, criticize SL and even oppose SL but why do you regurgitate the rhetoric and propaganda of our enemies? The term secession doesnt apply to SL, its something our enemies made up to delegitimize SL.Sxb ii waran horta. Where have you been hiding? Each to their own I say. Why do I need to have same views as you or any other secessionist? Does that make you feel less secure?
I am Isxaaq and I'm believer in the greater goal not this failed project that feeds only few handful thugs.
We know that Dofaar Ismaciil and Hutus have committed unprecedented acts of treachery since 1890, when they together with their fascist Italian master waged war against the legitimate rulers of southern Zoomalia. The idea that Dofaar and Hutu own the destiny of all Somalis stems from this era hence their duopoly politics. Even the notion of Somaliweyn (La Grande Somalia) was coined by their fascist father Mussolini.
Two mongrel clans that invited foreign troops to Somali soil, allowed nuclear waste to be dumped in coastal areas and even worse than that, raped, murdered and starved interriverine communities for personal gains, are now calling for "genuine" 'Somali unity' and 'Somali nationalism'. Do you really believe that?
We know these animals very well and their malign nature. Theres nothing honest about their crocodile tears.
There are some things I dont like about SL and its politics but I will always support my country. I believe Somalilanders should be more honest and allow constructive criticism.
Secondly, no doubt Somalis have done despicable shit to each other in the past decades, but NOT one Somali clan can claim to be uncontaminated by the disease that is tribalism. Your own Isaaq have committed atrocities in Borama and Dilla. And just like the Hawiye and Darod who brought in foreign militarys in to Somalia to serve their interests, the Isaaq have also created Somaliland to pursue their interests at the disadvantage of other clans. So were all affected by wicked qabyaalad.
The mistake in the 1960 acts was corrected later in January 1961 with the Act of Union. Thus, both the State of Somalia and the State of Somaliland ceased to exist as legal entities and was replaced by the Somali Republic.The word is secede. You do not secede from a union, you dissolve it.Firstly, Somaliland is unilaterally succeeding from Somalia since it does not have the legitimacy to dissolve the union.
You can believe whatever you want sxb, criticize SL and even oppose SL but why do you regurgitate the rhetoric and propaganda of our enemies? The term secession doesnt apply to SL, its something our enemies made up to delegitimize SL.
We know that Dofaar Ismaciil and Hutus have committed unprecedented acts of treachery since 1890, when they together with their fascist Italian master waged war against the legitimate rulers of southern Zoomalia. The idea that Dofaar and Hutu own the destiny of all Somalis stems from this era hence their duopoly politics. Even the notion of Somaliweyn (La Grande Somalia) was coined by their fascist father Mussolini.
Two mongrel clans that invited foreign troops to Somali soil, allowed nuclear waste to be dumped in coastal areas and even worse than that, raped, murdered and starved interriverine communities for personal gains, are now calling for "genuine" 'Somali unity' and 'Somali nationalism'. Do you really believe that?
We know these animals very well and their malign nature. Theres nothing honest about their crocodile tears.
There are some things I dont like about SL and its politics but I will always support my country. I believe Somalilanders should be more honest and allow constructive criticism.
Secondly, no doubt Somalis have done despicable shit to each other in the past decades, but NOT one Somali clan can claim to be uncontaminated by the disease that is tribalism. Your own Isaaq have committed atrocities in Borama and Dilla. And just like the Hawiye and Darod who brought in foreign militarys in to Somalia to serve their interests, the Isaaq have also created Somaliland to pursue their interests at the disadvantage of other clans. So were all affected by wicked qabyaalad.
Secondly, we ratified the Act of Union in Hargeisa on June 27, 1960 because we were sincere about Somaliweyn but the mongrels of Zoomalia did not ratify the bilateral treaty thus making the union null and void, as presented by the AU fact finding mission of 2005.
Somalilands case is more than legitimate. Our biggest obstacle is geopolitics.
Few Isaaq avenged their loved ones who were killed by Gudabiirsi faqash militia despite SNM warnings of not harming anyone. Nonetheless, less than 100 people were killed in Awdal.
Now compare that to the crimes committed by the treacherous Dofaar Ismaciil and Hutus against the interriverine communities that lead to the deaths of 300.000 civilians because of a man made famine.
Today the mongrels Dofaar Ismaciil and Hutu are using AMISOM against the same communities that they harmed in the past, accusing them of being AS because they want to steal their land.
Isaaq is honorable. We sacrificed more than all clans combined for the fake Somaliweyn and ungrateful Zoomalis.
The actual legal case for Somaliland's independence is not up for debate, beyond the AU fact-finding mission mentioned by Xildiid above, the Office of Chief Government Law Advisor of South Africa issued their official opinion on the issue of Somaliland's independence, clearly stating that Somaliland does qualify for independence as a sovereign state. This is the law advisor of the government of South Africa.The mistake in the 1960 acts was corrected later in January 1961 with the Act of Union. Thus, both the State of Somalia and the State of Somaliland ceased to exist as legal entities and was replaced by the Somali Republic.The word is secede. You do not secede from a union, you dissolve it.
Firstly, Somaliland is unilaterally succeeding from Somalia since it does not have the legitimacy to dissolve the union.
Secondly, no doubt Somalis have done despicable shit to each other in the past decades, but NOT one Somali clan can claim to be uncontaminated by the disease that is tribalism. Your own Isaaq have committed atrocities in Borama and Dilla. And just like the Hawiye and Darod who brought in foreign militarys in to Somalia to serve their interests, the Isaaq have also created Somaliland to pursue their interests at the disadvantage of other clans. So were all affected by wicked qabyaalad.
Secondly, we ratified the Act of Union in Hargeisa on June 27, 1960 because we were sincere about Somaliweyn but the mongrels of Zoomalia did not ratify the bilateral treaty thus making the union null and void, as presented by the AU fact finding mission of 2005.
Somalilands case is more than legitimate. Our biggest obstacle is geopolitics.
Few Isaaq avenged their loved ones who were killed by Gudabiirsi faqash militia despite SNM warnings of not harming anyone. Nonetheless, less than 100 people were killed in Awdal.
Now compare that to the crimes committed by the treacherous Dofaar Ismaciil and Hutus against the interriverine communities that lead to the deaths of 300.000 civilians because of a man made famine.
Today the mongrels Dofaar Ismaciil and Hutu are using AMISOM against the same communities that they harmed in the past, accusing them of being AS because they want to steal their land.
Isaaq is honorable. We sacrificed more than all clans combined for the fake Somaliweyn and ungrateful Zoomalis.
Therefore, neither of those former states can dissolve the union because there were no terms about a possible dissolution of the union. In fact the first Article of Somaliland's Act of 1960 stated "the State of Somaliland and the State of Somalia do hereby unite and shall forever remain united".
Hence, the modern day Somaliland has no legitimacy to dissolve the union (Nor would the former State of Somalia be able to), as it is simply seceding from the Somali Republic - and that is illegal both in domestic and international law. Read the case Reference Re Secession of Quebec, [1998] 2 SCR 217.
The drafted Act of Union of 1960 was accepted as a legitimate bilateral treaty by both parties.The mistake in the 1960 acts was corrected later in January 1961 with the Act of Union. Thus, both the State of Somalia and the State of Somaliland ceased to exist as legal entities and was replaced by the Somali Republic.The word is secede. You do not secede from a union, you dissolve it.
Firstly, Somaliland is unilaterally succeeding from Somalia since it does not have the legitimacy to dissolve the union.
Secondly, no doubt Somalis have done despicable shit to each other in the past decades, but NOT one Somali clan can claim to be uncontaminated by the disease that is tribalism. Your own Isaaq have committed atrocities in Borama and Dilla. And just like the Hawiye and Darod who brought in foreign militarys in to Somalia to serve their interests, the Isaaq have also created Somaliland to pursue their interests at the disadvantage of other clans. So were all affected by wicked qabyaalad.
Secondly, we ratified the Act of Union in Hargeisa on June 27, 1960 because we were sincere about Somaliweyn but the mongrels of Zoomalia did not ratify the bilateral treaty thus making the union null and void, as presented by the AU fact finding mission of 2005.
Somalilands case is more than legitimate. Our biggest obstacle is geopolitics.
Few Isaaq avenged their loved ones who were killed by Gudabiirsi faqash militia despite SNM warnings of not harming anyone. Nonetheless, less than 100 people were killed in Awdal.
Now compare that to the crimes committed by the treacherous Dofaar Ismaciil and Hutus against the interriverine communities that lead to the deaths of 300.000 civilians because of a man made famine.
Today the mongrels Dofaar Ismaciil and Hutu are using AMISOM against the same communities that they harmed in the past, accusing them of being AS because they want to steal their land.
Isaaq is honorable. We sacrificed more than all clans combined for the fake Somaliweyn and ungrateful Zoomalis.
Therefore, neither of those former states can dissolve the union because there were no terms about a possible dissolution of the union. In fact the first Article of Somaliland's Act of 1960 stated "the State of Somaliland and the State of Somalia do hereby unite and shall forever remain united".
Hence, the modern day Somaliland has no legitimacy to dissolve the union (Nor would the former State of Somalia be able to), as it is simply seceding from the Somali Republic - and that is illegal both in domestic and international law. Read the case Reference Re Secession of Quebec, [1998] 2 SCR 217.
Sxb, all Somali clans have done uncondonable things against their fellow Somalis and the Isaaq are not an exception.
The Darod might of invited AMISOM into Somalia but the Isaaq have decided to unilaterally break up the country. I find the later is worse.
lol The Isaaq didn't unite with Somalia for the sake of Somalinimo, they did it because they wanted the Hawd and Reserve area to be brought back from Ethiopia. Once they realized this was not possible after the 1977 war, they decided to actively engage in treacherous acts to break up the country.
Its all about self interest,
The Darod are the biggest proponents of Somaliweyn today not because due to their love for Somalinimo but because they would gain the most by a greater Somalia. The Hawiye are comfortable as long as the capital remains Mogadishu.
The interriverine people you refer to want land they have vacated long ago and don't belong to them anymore, in Gedo and the two Jubbas - which is unreasonable and unacceptable. Its would be like the Dhulbahante laying claim to El Afweyn and Gar'adag, land they haven't settled in over a century.
Also, Al Shabab contains all Somali clans including Isaaq and no particular clan is blamed. In fact the majority of its members today are Hawiye, so I don't know were you get that info from.
Return to “Politics - General Discussions”
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 15 guests