Qodobada kasoo baxay shirka beesha direed

[Sauron]

There is no point in trying to reason with a brain dead cagdheer. waa iska neef.

[BestPlaya]

There is no point in trying to reason with a brain dead cagdheer. waa iska neef.

You wrong Ben Dover

It is you multnicking son of a b*tch and the rest of desperate iidorr crew who firmly belive and take it to heart anything written by white gaal . My argument is sound and clear .

Adiguba waad ogtahay sxb , labo neef oo iidoor ah ayaa garacnimo kugu dhalay .marka waxba hayska waaalin sinjigaagii bah dilnaa ee iidoorka ahaa wasse

[Xildiiid]

A renowned linguists is not credible enough because his impartial, extensive field study disproved Dofaar Ismaciil lies.

Not to mention that the study was carried out during the reign of Afweyne before they accuse Iidoor of funding the study.

Poetry is Isaaq culture! Only Dofaars (Cagdheer and Qurji) that border Isaaq adopted this culture from us.

Where are the MareXaar poets? Leelkase? Awrtabla? Gerri? Jidwaaq? maJAREERteen?

This further proves my point.

[BestPlaya]

A renowned linguists is not credible enough because his impartial, extensive field study disproved Dofaar Ismaciil lies.

Not to mention that the study was carried out during the reign of Afweyne before they accuse Iidoor of funding the study.

Poetry is Isaaq culture! Only Dofaars (Cagdheer and Qurji) that border Isaaq adopted this culture from us.

Where are the MareXaar poets? Leelkase? Awrtabla? Gerri? Jidwaaq? maJAREERteen?

This further proves my point.

In poetry ,Ogaden come first then iidoors and dhulos.That's is well known fact .

[Xildiiid]

Those "white guys" had PhD in linguistics. Show us your credentials? Where's your study?

Buurmadow wont save you from humiliation in this thread yaa Cagdheer

Nonsense, Isaaq is king when it comes to classic Somali poetry. Cagdheer and Qurji adopted this culture from Isaaq because its absent in other Dofaar Ismaciils that do not border Isaaq.

[BestPlaya]

Those "white guys" had PhD in linguistics. Show us your credentials? Where's your study?

Buurmadow wont save you from humiliation in this thread yaa Cagdheer

Nonsense, Isaaq is king when it comes to classic Somali poetry. Cagdheer and Qurji adopted this culture from Isaaq because its absent in other Dofaar Ismaciils that do not border Isaaq.

Yeah ,probably they have PHD in linguistics but Somali is not their area of expertise .A white man with a PHD doesn't know it all .He's not answer to everything contrary to your weird beliefs


I repeatedly thrashed hordes of iidoor lowlifes .let them just keep coming .


What do you know about poetry iidoor nigga .Ogaden poets and poetry are the finest in history .Poetry is not absent from others Daarood clans it is only that you don't know .

[DayrBare]

You discredit yourself by engaging in insulting people which proofs that you lost it. you got to lay this long essay of yours to rest because they are not facts rather hearsay.

This debate needs ending because it reached its limit, let other people who can present scholarly work resume it.

I am done here. Noloshu Hakuu macaanato, dhamaanteenba

[luis1]

Xiliddid:

Luis,

Nonsense.

Up until 1988, Hawd and Shiniile were free from these proxy groups because of SNM which is something Mengistu himself admitted. There were no Soviet advisors left in 1988. They were busy fighting in Afghanistan against the taliban nor did Cuban soldiers fight these proxy groups.

I would like to see proofs about Mengistu opinion.

Talibans were created in 1994. They did not fight Soviet regime in Afghanistan.

Cuban soldiers fought SALF and WSLF until 1989 when they left Ethiopia.

The reality is Cubans and Ethiopians crushed WSLF and SALF and pacified Ogaden.

[Salaxbaashe]

Poetry is isaaq culture and those who border us. Waa ayaandaro in wiil yar oo an Abti uu yahaay inu sheegto daqaankayga.

[BestPlaya]

You discredit yourself by engaging in insulting people which proofs that you lost it. you got to lay this long essay of yours to rest because they are not facts rather hearsay.

This debate needs ending because it reached its limit, let other people who can present scholarly work resume it.

I am done here. Noloshu Hakuu macaanato, dhamaanteenba

Scholarly work ?

What kind of scholarly work do you want .A biased poorly written work of Gaal cadaan ah ? Yet you stubbornly trying to descredit my sound argument as "hearsay" ?

Aapahaagii iidoorka ahaa ee xaqirnaaa wasss ..silac kunooshiiyeey

[BestPlaya]

Poetry is isaaq culture and those who border us. Waa ayaandaro in wiil yar oo an Abti uu yahaay inu sheegto daqaankayga.

Hooyadaadiii sacsac muuse ah ahayd wasss ..waxaad ka dhalatay qoloda afka noosha ah ee iidoor ugu dabacsan .Markaad faantamaysaana waxaad golaha la imaataan suugaantii iyo loolankii Garaxjis kala dhexeeyay Maxamad Subeer.

Sacsac muusaa tahay bilaa taarikh ah....Irbad dhuub ma galisaan ,Afkuna weydun dheeryahaye

Sugaanta waxaa u sita oo marag ma doonta ah Ogaden ,waxaa kaalinta labaad isku cidhbiya iidoor iyo dhulbaante . wataa xaqiiqadu.

[Hennystreak]

I dont even know any idoor poets except Hadraawi, who by the way wasnt even classical poet.

When it comes to Somali poietry;

1. Dhulbahante

2.Ogaden

3. Marexaan

4.Idoor

[DayrBare]

You discredit yourself by engaging in insulting people which proofs that you lost it. you got to lay this long essay of yours to rest because they are not facts rather hearsay.

This debate needs ending because it reached its limit, let other people who can present scholarly work resume it.

I am done here. Noloshu Hakuu macaanato, dhamaanteenba

Scholarly work ?

What kind of scholarly work do you want .A biased poorly written work of Gaal cadaan ah ? Yet you stubbornly trying to descredit my sound argument as "hearsay" ?

Aapahaagii iidoorka ahaa ee xaqirnaaa wasss ..silac kunooshiiyeey

I am not going stoop to insulting you or your Cagdheer ancestor. If there was any credibility in your hearsays, it no longer does.

Idoor was, is and will always be relevant among the Somalis and any reprehensible thig you say will not diminish that.

We can’t keep replying back and forth to each other so Have a nice life.

[Xildiiid]

Those "white guys" had PhD in linguistics. Show us your credentials? Where's your study?

Buurmadow wont save you from humiliation in this thread yaa Cagdheer

Nonsense, Isaaq is king when it comes to classic Somali poetry. Cagdheer and Qurji adopted this culture from Isaaq because its absent in other Dofaar Ismaciils that do not border Isaaq.

Yeah ,probably they have PHD in linguistics but Somali is not their area of expertise .A white man with a PHD doesn't know it all .He's not answer to everything contrary to your weird beliefs


I repeatedly thrashed hordes of iidoor lowlifes .let them just keep coming .


What do you know about poetry iidoor nigga .Ogaden poets and poetry are the finest in history .


Poetry is not absent from others Daarood clans it is only that you don't know .

Unlike you, an Cagdheer driven by emotions, these men were authorities in their field and the result of their study was something we Isaaq always knew.

Isaaq dialect = standard Somali

Who did you trash and what did you prove? You are truly delusional

Isaaq are kings when it comes to classic Somali poetry. Your own Dofaar Ismaciil testified in front of Luigi Robecchi that the best poet of their times was Isaaq and that Raage Ugaaz envied and feared Axmad Adan Dubbe aka Gabay Xoog

[Hennystreak]

Those "white guys" had PhD in linguistics. Show us your credentials? Where's your study?

Buurmadow wont save you from humiliation in this thread yaa Cagdheer

Nonsense, Isaaq is king when it comes to classic Somali poetry. Cagdheer and Qurji adopted this culture from Isaaq because its absent in other Dofaar Ismaciils that do not border Isaaq.

Yeah ,probably they have PHD in linguistics but Somali is not their area of expertise .A white man with a PHD doesn't know it all .He's not answer to everything contrary to your weird beliefs


I repeatedly thrashed hordes of iidoor lowlifes .let them just keep coming .


What do you know about poetry iidoor nigga .Ogaden poets and poetry are the finest in history .


Poetry is not absent from others Daarood clans it is only that you don't know .

Unlike you, an Cagdheer driven by emotions, these men were authorities in their field and the result of their study was something we Isaaq always knew.

Isaaq dialect = standard Somali

Who did you trash and what did you prove? You are truly delusional

Isaaq are kings when it comes to classic Somali poetry. Your own Dofaar Ismaciil testified in front of Luigi Robecchi that the best poet of their times was Isaaq and that Raage Ugaaz envied and feared Axmad Adan Dubbe aka Gabay Xoog

^ Idoorku xishood ma leh. kkk, walee yaab anagaa aragnaay. Who tf is Gabay Xoog? It sounds like the guy was overcompensating for his inadequacies not to mention the fact that he is unknown.


Northern dialect isnt exclusive idoor, its a regional dialect. Their isnt a clan dialect per se.


Dhulbahante and Ogadeen poets are revered in Idoor households and not even the idoors can name you 4 idoor poets off the bat.

in myrhh and Gums. Poetry originated from the Dolbahanta country and made its way into the Ogaden highlands. The gulbed clans who settle the great expanse of lifeless plains called the Guban are not known for their prose but rather their gallantry.

Here is an excerpt from Richard Burton