Moderator: Moderators
This is why so-called Somali federalism is gonna be history in a few years. In other federal countries, you've a governor as the top leader in a federal state, and no president, ministers, parliament, defense, foreign affairs, etc like in SL, PL and JL.What is wrong with these folks? Do they think they are an independent country. They think they can have one foot in and one foot out. Hadey xornimo rabaan ha cadeyan. First we have them telling the prime minister of a country he entered north galkacyo “si sharci daro”. If somaliland splits, south Somalia should also split from Puntland.
No mr anarchist Kunax.This is why so-called Somali federalism is gonna be history in a few years. In other federal countries, you've a governor as the top leader in a federal state, and no president, ministers, parliament, defense, foreign affairs, etc like in SL, PL and JL.What is wrong with these folks? Do they think they are an independent country. They think they can have one foot in and one foot out. Hadey xornimo rabaan ha cadeyan. First we have them telling the prime minister of a country he entered north galkacyo “si sharci daro”. If somaliland splits, south Somalia should also split from Puntland.
There is a reason why it was easy for puntland project to work. When u have one subclan living in each region with no one else, and sparsely populated land it is much easier than the densely populated south with 14 clans in some regions. Puntland should be given some xushmad and should be given a bit more leeway then other federal states as they have been doing this for 20 years. There will be some crises in other federal states once shabaab is gone that is for sure.No mr anarchist Kunax.This is why so-called Somali federalism is gonna be history in a few years. In other federal countries, you've a governor as the top leader in a federal state, and no president, ministers, parliament, defense, foreign affairs, etc like in SL, PL and JL.What is wrong with these folks? Do they think they are an independent country. They think they can have one foot in and one foot out. Hadey xornimo rabaan ha cadeyan. First we have them telling the prime minister of a country he entered north galkacyo “si sharci daro”. If somaliland splits, south Somalia should also split from Puntland.
You cant go on creating instability in regions that have been successful for more than 20 years.Just being inside Ugandan tank doesnt guarantee you any oowers to meddle with federal states creation you need to sort out xamar before trying to destroy and dismantle federal states.
Museveni and US president resently called Somalia failed state and the main reason is because instead of the government investing in dismantling AS and creating a national military as well as reviving basic instituions in the capital it is busy trying to dismantle the beam of hope emanating from other regions kudayo PL should be the motto.
But what do you know of someone who was a Baree Hiraale supporter when PL was being formed from grass roots.
It was PL efforts that created the central government not the other way round nor Farmajo was there when PL was heavily involved in laying the foundation of a central government.
One subclan? There is leilkase,MJ,Dishishle,Dhulbahante and warsengeli.There is a reason why it was easy for puntland project to work. When u have one subclan living in each region with no one else, and sparsely populated land it is much easier than the densely populated south with 14 clans in some regions. Puntland should be given some xushmad and should be given a bit more leeway then other federal states as they have been doing this for 20 years. There will be some crises in other federal states once shabaab is gone that is for sure.No mr anarchist Kunax.This is why so-called Somali federalism is gonna be history in a few years. In other federal countries, you've a governor as the top leader in a federal state, and no president, ministers, parliament, defense, foreign affairs, etc like in SL, PL and JL.
You cant go on creating instability in regions that have been successful for more than 20 years.Just being inside Ugandan tank doesnt guarantee you any oowers to meddle with federal states creation you need to sort out xamar before trying to destroy and dismantle federal states.
Museveni and US president resently called Somalia failed state and the main reason is because instead of the government investing in dismantling AS and creating a national military as well as reviving basic instituions in the capital it is busy trying to dismantle the beam of hope emanating from other regions kudayo PL should be the motto.
But what do you know of someone who was a Baree Hiraale supporter when PL was being formed from grass roots.
It was PL efforts that created the central government not the other way round nor Farmajo was there when PL was heavily involved in laying the foundation of a central government.
Federal states will not work out long term in the south that is for sure. It is too volatile as for puntland omar Mahamud, ciise maxamuud etc live for thousands of miles with no one around them. In Galmudug, mareexan live literally on the border now. That is a lie that xamar is one qabiil dominated. Maybe 10 years ago.The mareexans in xamar ciida ey ka badan yahiin. raxanweyn are the largest after hiiraab. Bro there is now thousands of isaaq who live in xamar believe it or not.One subclan? There is leilkase,MJ,Dishishle,Dhulbahante and warsengeli.There is a reason why it was easy for puntland project to work. When u have one subclan living in each region with no one else, and sparsely populated land it is much easier than the densely populated south with 14 clans in some regions. Puntland should be given some xushmad and should be given a bit more leeway then other federal states as they have been doing this for 20 years. There will be some crises in other federal states once shabaab is gone that is for sure.
No mr anarchist Kunax.
You cant go on creating instability in regions that have been successful for more than 20 years.Just being inside Ugandan tank doesnt guarantee you any oowers to meddle with federal states creation you need to sort out xamar before trying to destroy and dismantle federal states.
Museveni and US president resently called Somalia failed state and the main reason is because instead of the government investing in dismantling AS and creating a national military as well as reviving basic instituions in the capital it is busy trying to dismantle the beam of hope emanating from other regions kudayo PL should be the motto.
But what do you know of someone who was a Baree Hiraale supporter when PL was being formed from grass roots.
It was PL efforts that created the central government not the other way round nor Farmajo was there when PL was heavily involved in laying the foundation of a central government.
Also if its one subclan how come Galmudug is fck up.
The only time I will give respect to a xamar based centralist state is when there are no foreign forces and they have abolute control of xamar be it in tax collection,judiciary like in ability to prosecute criminal elements as welk as running institutions.
Few photo ops by N&N will not gibe them upper hand against federal states.
War just look at SL and PL and tell me how the Villa Somalia regime has any closeness to them.
Xamar is one qabil dominated too.
No wonder US president refers to somalia as failed state and the foreign minister did not reply to counter his arguement.
Maxa ku harey marki wadanka gudafad layirahdo?
The failmajo regime is standing on one foot.Heavily relys on IC for donations as well as development of institutions like airports,hospitals,schools.built by Turks.Xamar has been recieving funds for the entire somalia sunce the time of Arta accord.That money hadly went to other regions.
No one said the south should be one state.Federal states will not work out long term in the south that is for sure. It is too volatile as for puntland omar Mahamud, ciise maxamuud etc live for thousands of miles with no one around them. In Galmudug, mareexan live literally on the border now. That is a lie that xamar is one qabiil dominated. Maybe 10 years ago.The mareexans in xamar ciida ey ka badan yahiin. raxanweyn are the largest after hiiraab. Bro there is now thousands of isaaq who live in xamar believe it or not.One subclan? There is leilkase,MJ,Dishishle,Dhulbahante and warsengeli.
There is a reason why it was easy for puntland project to work. When u have one subclan living in each region with no one else, and sparsely populated land it is much easier than the densely populated south with 14 clans in some regions. Puntland should be given some xushmad and should be given a bit more leeway then other federal states as they have been doing this for 20 years. There will be some crises in other federal states once shabaab is gone that is for sure.
Also if its one subclan how come Galmudug is fck up.
The only time I will give respect to a xamar based centralist state is when there are no foreign forces and they have abolute control of xamar be it in tax collection,judiciary like in ability to prosecute criminal elements as welk as running institutions.
Few photo ops by N&N will not gibe them upper hand against federal states.
War just look at SL and PL and tell me how the Villa Somalia regime has any closeness to them.
Xamar is one qabil dominated too.
No wonder US president refers to somalia as failed state and the foreign minister did not reply to counter his arguement.
Maxa ku harey marki wadanka gudafad layirahdo?
The failmajo regime is standing on one foot.Heavily relys on IC for donations as well as development of institutions like airports,hospitals,schools.built by Turks.Xamar has been recieving funds for the entire somalia sunce the time of Arta accord.That money hadly went to other regions.
What country is he talking about? Is he saying he considers Puntland a country?dalka sharci buu leeyahay
Saying Farmaajo can't do anything about this situation is one thing considering that Puntland actually functions as an independent unrecognized nation like Somaliland but what the hell is this idiot talking about saying Deni has no say in this matter? The fact that he claims Deni can't do anything about this is probably more outrages than the part about Farmaajo.Dacwad oogaha Puntland ayaa gabagabadii sheegay in madaxweyne Deni iyo madaxweyne Farmaajo uusan midkoona sii deyn karin dadka xiran, cidda awoodda lehna ay tahay sharciga oo waxa uu ka qabo lugu qaadi doono eedeysaneyaasha, sida uu sheegay.
Don’t put us along with Kufsi land and JubalandThis is why so-called Somali federalism is gonna be history in a few years. In other federal countries, you've a governor as the top leader in a federal state, and no president, ministers, parliament, defense, foreign affairs, etc like in SL, PL and JL.What is wrong with these folks? Do they think they are an independent country. They think they can have one foot in and one foot out. Hadey xornimo rabaan ha cadeyan. First we have them telling the prime minister of a country he entered north galkacyo “si sharci daro”. If somaliland splits, south Somalia should also split from Puntland.
TogdeerDon’t put us along with Kufsi land and JubalandThis is why so-called Somali federalism is gonna be history in a few years. In other federal countries, you've a governor as the top leader in a federal state, and no president, ministers, parliament, defense, foreign affairs, etc like in SL, PL and JL.What is wrong with these folks? Do they think they are an independent country. They think they can have one foot in and one foot out. Hadey xornimo rabaan ha cadeyan. First we have them telling the prime minister of a country he entered north galkacyo “si sharci daro”. If somaliland splits, south Somalia should also split from Puntland.
We are not a federal member state never have been and never will be. Keep telling yourself more lies if it makes you sleep better at night.
Each of JL, PL & Sl have president, ministers, parliament, defense, foreign affairs, etc--but none is recognized, so all are the same whether federal or not. Eventually, each will come under the control of the recognized central gov.Don’t put us along with Kufsi land and Jubaland
We are not a federal member state never have been and never will be. Keep telling yourself more lies if it makes you sleep better at night.
Bastaad waxa ah nasabkaga oo guun ah.Harti could have thier independent state, but Cagdheers and iiidoooors will be under our control ever. Doqonkii Cagdheer Django bastardo.
![]()
Return to “Politics - General Discussions”
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 12 guests