CaliQase wrote:Hyperactive wrote:good discussion, very civilized. not totally agree here but i like the train of thinking here both CaliQase and The Future.
many moons ago my sister asked me " can i pray in my room without hijab?" i asked what makes you think of that? she said "cause I am standing front of Allah when i pray and give respect and thank to him, he can see me under the cloth, so how one can cover from God"
i understood how her train of thinking going, she was thinking, if hijab is to cover "your beauty, be modest or what ever from strange men, why cover from God.
i encoureged her to continue to think and ask as much questions and do not scare of no body to ask. love it.
one has to consider the circumferences and the audiance all the time.
Where do you stand on this one?
where i stand is mine and it's not shar'a(my qool is not shar'a) . while we're in it let us first know what some scholars point of veiw (point; i really hate people who say, sheikh/scholar said this or that, instead Allah said this or that and prophet!)
Hanafia said: the whole body of woman is "owrah" except her "inside her hand/baatin hand, same her feet" in salat.
Shafi'etyah said; all woman's body is "awrah" except hand and face, both salat or outside salat.
Hanabila said same as shafi'ea, except they said" free woman/7orah" face only! (where is slave woman now!!)
Malikia said (my own madhab) ; they divide woman's "owrah" in salat to two; "awrah ghaleedah" and "mokhafafah" if i direct translate would be ..awrada adag iyo tan khafifka ah. the adag wa all body except arms, legs, back and the chest area except breasts.
the"owrah mokhafafah" is chest, back, arms, from knees until end of feet, dace, hands and feet not "awrah" at all.
so Almalika says, who showed their " hard Awrah" with affording to cover her prayers is "batilah" and needs to redo it.
if she shows her "awra mokhafadfah wich is; hair, chest, whole arms, from knees to down" her salat is is "not batilah" but " it's haraam or makrooh" but she doesnt have to redo it. he added, men shouldnt look at her. it's "better/ma7abab/recommended" to cover it and redo it when she covers it. for Almalikiyah, it's different than "libaas alshar'i or term we use these day as woman's hijab"
God knows best.