Postby Salahuddiin » Mon May 11, 2009 10:49 pm
Kolombo bro, I ask you the same question I asked in the topic about cutting hands:
So who do you support generally? Current leaders who rule by kufr, wage war against islam ideologically and are secularizing their people and institutions day by day and support USA and other countries in physical war against muslims?
Or are you waiting for a third option that is perfect without mistakes that will never come?
These groups that you talk about may have ghuluu in some issues and no doubt they make mistakes, like every single person in this world. But they are trying to bring islamic governance that will replace governance by kufr and they are trying to bring cizza to muslims, to replace people who are against islam and muslims. So which one is better, and can muslim really prefer current order?
Are mistakes by these groups reason strong enough not to support them and forget islam ever getting back the cizza? Have you studied Islamic history and governance of Umayads, Abbasids and Ottomans not to mention hundreds of smaller kingdoms in muslim world? After khulafaa ur raashidiin you find great mistakes in governance and many other issues, like you will find in every single society. Again, no one is perfect and free of mistakes, but the thing that counts is what they are doing and what are their objectives. And what we need and what is fard on this ummah is establishing an islamic state.
Are you following the advice of scholars of rulers, who say that until there is 100% tawhiid and muslims are almost perfect, there's no sharica, jihad or anything that affects society politically? This day will never come before Ciisaa, and this way Wallaahi is a way to destruction of Islam. A way to passivate and secularize muslims, so in the end only they think that religion is inside the masjid.
And if you are following some particular shuyukh that say something to this fashion, try to search if they had fataawaa about the Soviet war in Afghanistan. And by studying the history we'll find out that this war had the same problems that conflict areas and groups have today. And still jihad and support for it was compulsory. Now compare these fatwas to fatwas of today in exactly the same situations, and you'll maybe realize there might be something else behind them than sincerity.