A theory as to why Somalia is so backwards

[ModerateMuslim]

My reaction to both is the same...

so you react the same way to slander and mockery of islam as you do about saying the jews are descendants of swines and pigs (something all scholars of worth have said one time or onther)?

[suga_delic]

Somalis r backward nt bcoz of Islam, bt bcz of us tryin 2 mix culture n religion. Da onli culture that suppose 2 exist is Islam, bt if we developed this notion of brotherhood by clan, by blood rather than by Ummah, thats were Somalis went wrong. U cnt have 2 different ways of life. 1 dat is based on the teachings n culture of our forefathers. N 1 that is words of allah n teachins of da prophet pbuh. They going 2 clash at sum point. Nw we have a nation dat want 2 keep their backwarded teachings of forefathers,the tribel belief, n the religion of god.

[Voltage]

My reaction to both is the same...

so you react the same way to slander and mockery of islam as you do about saying the jews are descendants of swines and pigs (something all scholars of worth have said one time or onther)?

I react the same way to ignornace but clearly Islam is not equal to anything which is why I called for this i.diot's banishment.

[Voltage]

It doesn't look like a theory to me; more like a personal opinion.

First time agreed with Arabman.

[ModerateMuslim]

I react the same way to ignornace but clearly Islam is not equal to anything which is why I called for this i.diot's banishment.

so its 'ignorance' and 'idiotic' on my part - not to speak of all the classic scholars - to say that the jews are descendants of apes and pigs because allah, exalted be he, turned some of their ancestors into apes and and pigs for abandoning the laws send down by allah swt and instead turning to their taghut rabbis to decide for them what's halal and what's haram? and this is somehow comparable to someone slandering islam?

in that case, you've serious issues. may allah guide you.