Moderators: Moderators, Junior Moderators
This is a clear defeat.Somalia could not capture Ogaden in 1978.
WSLF was defeated afterwards
Ethiopia became stronger than Somalia after Ogaden War
Somalia was weaker and was not a serious military hreat to Ethiopia after Ogaden War.
"A great civilization is not conquered from without until it has destroyed itself within"
-Will Durant
Farah, Nuruddin.“The idea of the . . . trilogy is centered around the notion of an orphaned nation . . . I had in mind to have orphans as the central consciousness of each of the novels, and this serves as the trilogy's thematic concern," the author says. "As a general, Siad Barre [the national leader ousted during the 1991 uprising] fails the Somali nation when the national army is defeated at the hands of the combined efforts of Ethiopia, Cuba, and the then-Soviet Union. He fails a second time when he doesn't resign as soon as the defeated national army returns to base. Defeat is an implosive nature, an infestation capable of poisoning the body-politic of a people. Somalia, as a result, begins to rely on foreign aid. And Secrets is the novel in which it all explodes.”
Find me sources which prove your point of view.It wasn't a defeat. It was a strategic decision made by the Somali military.
Somalia was victorious, especially during the beginning of the war. The Somali army were deep into the Ogaden region and were just a few miles away from Addis Ababa.
Certain distractions, like the Soviet assistance, was hindering Somalia's goal of freeing the Ogaden region.
As a result of these distractions, Somalia withdrew.
It wasn't a defeat
Yusuf is accepting Somalia was defeated.Poor political leadership lay at the core of the defeat of the somali army in this war.Following the defeat and withdrawal of the battle theatre
But Somali Army was almost destroyed,look at these casualties:Soviet assistance made Somalia reconsider their strategies and they decided to withdraw
The Ogaden War weakened the Somali military. Almost one-third of the regular SNA soldiers, three-eighths of the armored units and half of the Somali Air Force (SAF) were lost. The weakness of the Barre regime led it to effectively abandon the dream of a unified Greater Somalia. The failure of the war aggravated discontent with the Barre regime; the first organized opposition group, the Somali Salvation Democratic Front (SSDF), was formed by army officers in 1979
Wikipedia is very clear,Siad Barre position in Ogaden was untenable,so He retired his army from Ogaden.From October 1977 until January 1978, the SNA-WSLF forces attempted to capture Harar, where 40,000 Ethiopians had regrouped and re-armed with Soviet-supplied artillery and armor; backed by 1500 Soviet "advisors" and 11,000 Cuban soldiers, they engaged the attackers in vicious fighting. Though the Somali forces reached the city outskirts by November, they were too exhausted to take the city and eventually had to withdraw to await the Ethiopian counterattack.
The expected Ethiopian-Cuban attack occurred in early February; however, it was accompanied by a second attack that the Somalis did not expect. A column of Ethiopian and Cuban troops crossed northeast into the highlands between Jijiga and the border with Somalia, bypassing the SNA-WSLF force defending the Marda Pass. The attackers were thus able to assault from two directions in a "pincer" action, allowing the re-capture of Jijiga in only two days while killing 3,000 defenders. The Somali defense collapsed and every major Ethiopian town was recaptured in the following weeks. Recognizing that his position was untenable, Siad Barre ordered the SNA to retreat back into Somalia on 9 March 1978, although Rene LaFort claims that the Somalis, having foreseen the inevitable, had already withdrawn its heavy weapons.The last significant Somali unit left Ethiopia on 15 March 1978, marking the end of the war.
Effects of the warFollowing the withdrawal of the SNA, the WSLF continued their insurgency. By May 1980, the rebels, with the assistance of a small number of SNA soldiers who continued to help the guerilla war, controlled a substantial region of the Ogaden. However by 1981 the insurgents were reduced to sporadic hit-and-run attacks and were finally defeated.
The Ogaden War weakened the Somali military. Almost one-third of the regular SNA soldiers, three-eighths of the armored units and half of the Somali Air Force (SAF) were lost. The weakness of the Barre regime led it to effectively abandon the dream of a unified Greater Somalia. The failure of the war aggravated discontent with the Barre regime; the first organized opposition group, the Somali Salvation Democratic Front (SSDF), was formed by army officers in 1979.
Soviets were defeated pretty bad till the the weather changed to their advantage. Germany was and still is in its own league when it comes to innovation, engineering and perfection.
Return to “General - General Discussions”
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 50 guests
