Hodan and Elmi Did not exist

[Minneapolis Mayor]

I have seen somali people fighting over Dhagaxtuur and Xaawo Taako. They believe they were real people even though they were just monoments of the struggle. Dhagaxtuur represented men's struggle and Xaawo Taako represents women's struggle. They never existed in real essense.

Yes, Axmad Gurey was not a somali. He was a mujaahid Arab.

[DR-YALAXOOW]

GEESIGII Xalane.. the man who 1964 somali ethiopian war, according the history. markii ciidanka somalia la soo riixay ayuu arkay calankii Somalia buluuga ahaa oo axmaarada ciidankeediii ka gadaal maray. ayuu Geesi MR XALANE inoo dhufeeyska ka baxay ayuu xabado riday isagoo qaylinaya sidii RAMBO ayuu dilay axmaaro baddan. CIIDANKII ethiopianka xabado ayey kala daaleen mr xalane laakiin xalano oo dhiig ka socda ayaa calankii buluuga soo dejiyey oo isku duubay markaasuuu dib ugu soo laabtay bartii ay ciidanka somali army joogeen. xalane oo siii naf baxaya ayaa gabay u tiriyey CALANKA SOMALIYEED QIIMAHA UU LEEYAHAY. ALLAH YAA RAXMA XALANE GEESIGII WAA GEERIYOODAY ISAGOO CALANKIII KU DUUB DUUBAN YAHAY..

WALAAHI this story iskuulada ayaa noolugu dhigi jiray. halyeey xalane waxaa lagu samiyey DUGSIGA TABABARKA CIIDANKA EE MOGADISHU KU YAALA EE MAANTA LOO YAQAAN XARUNTA TABABARKA EE XALANE near mogadishu airport..

and nasiib xumo this story is made up.. yes xalane existed and he past away 1964 somalia vs ethiopia war.. but kacaankii siyaad barre made up this story..

and yes xalane was hawiye.. sababtoo ah kacaanka wuxuu doonayey in uu abuuro geesiyaal soomaali oo dhan ka socda not only sayid maxamed abdulle xasan si aan kacaanka loogu qaadan mid u xaglinaya qabiil gaar ah..

marka brothers and sisters there are many fictional stories who humans being brainwashed to believe..

[IRONm@N]

History revisionist. so basically you saying if you don't have a video or a picture of them, they all fictional. so what is next?
ahmed Gurey and Olol Diinle didn't exist

Listen my friend for example maxamed abdulle hassan as historical person did existed. but the status of being hero and gabyaa and geat somali leader is fabricated one. for example houndred of allegged sayid maxamed abdulle xassan poems surfaced when siyaad bare become president whit out any evidance existance manuscribts of such gabayo existed.

its like todays ABUU MANSUUR( al shabaab eelaay) year 2113 people of baydhabo make up story of Abuu mansuur al eelaay who lived 1968 to 2020 was great hero who fought against world and he was great gabygaaa. and people of baydhaboland in 2113 will believe such story 100% because they was not here when abuu mansuur was alive..

marka sxb its easy to make up story when all people who lived that persons life time do not live anymore....

I could believe ppl like Cigaal Shidaad or Dhagdheer, but Sayid Maxamed Abdulle is just 1920s, its not only Somali made up things, but foriegn countries were invovled such as British, Turkey, and Ethiopia, there are hundreds of letters, newspaper stories, anecodates, books and evidence in the British Meusuem about him.
A lot poems surface during Maxamed Siyad Barre's Era because that is when the Somali language and literature was collected and written down. and that is when most of the Somali were exposed to, as he was a Northern figure, not that much known in the South.

[DR-YALAXOOW]

the historical person of maxmed abdulle xasan did existed but kacaanka sexaggerated hes status or what cause he as fighting for and hes importance and as you know for there is no a singel foto of the sayid maxamed abdulle hasaan...

[X.Playa]

yes Elmi boodhari story is a fabricated one... Yes a man called Elmi nicnamed boodhari existed. and elmi boodhari use to work bread factory in berbera.. and year after he died a natural causes, this love story of elmi died because of jaceeyl of hodan surfaced.. so probably the story is just fictional....

there are many stories which was exaggerated for example sayid mohamed abdula hassan is exaggerated and hes status of a somali hero is a fictional. and all poems which said sayid maxamed abdulle hassans gabays is made up 50 years after hes death...

and wiil waal never existed as cigaal shidaad never existed.. so there are many made up stories through out history...

How is it fictional when him and the woman existed and we have the story written in 1964 along number of his poems by foreigners.

[DonCorleone]

I have seen somali people fighting over Dhagaxtuur and Xaawo Taako. They believe they were real people even though they were just monoments of the struggle. Dhagaxtuur represented men's struggle and Xaawo Taako represents women's struggle. They never existed in real essense.

Yes, Axmad Gurey was not a somali. He was a mujaahid Arab.

are you an ethiopian?

ahmed gurey was i believe dir irir from gadabursi or isse he was somali from zeylac



lol everyone else existed

lol snetter did yall notice certian people trying to say somali historical people did not exist

they want to erase the history we have by lying and saying, he/she is arab etc.

LIES.

f-king idiot where's the proof he was an arab man?



motherfucking fake

[CushiticReflections]

Cilmi Boodhari was a fiction story just like Qays and Leyla.

What is the story of Qays and Leyla?

[DonCorleone]

Cilmi Boodhari was a fiction story just like Qays and Leyla.

What is the story of Qays and Leyla?

I think its an arab romeo and juliet i don't remember

ill ask my sis

[MujahidAishah]

So if boodhari doesnt exist why does he hve a grave
Go watch harari iyo hargeysa they show his sister and hoodan grandkids oops I forget they dont exist either


Like axmed ali egal said

Baddu inay madow taday
Biyo tahay ma moogtayhay
Boodhari ba caashaqu
Badtaale inu dhiigu
Oo la soo booqodo maa oogtahay

[Meyle]

Yalaxow nin weyn baan kuu heystey laakin caruurnimadaadi baa soo baxday, you often speak about things that you have no clue about for instance IQ and IQ tests in which I debunked your claims and now you have the nerve to say that Cilmi Bodhari didnt exist? Its better to remain silent and be thought a fool then to open your mouth and remove all doubt.

[DR-YALAXOOW]

Meyle 1980s the son of hodan ayaa la wareeystay he siad hes mother never knew or saw such man called cilmi.
Elmi as person existed he lived 1930s in berbera but so called hodan elm love story is bogus fabricated one.

[Meyle]

Meyle 1980s the son of hodan ayaa la wareeystay he siad hes mother never knew or saw such man called cilmi.
Elmi as person existed he lived 1930s in berbera but so called hodan elm love story is bogus fabricated one.

You can criticize the love story but to say that the man didnt exist is absurd. The love story was exaggerated by Somalis but he fell in love with Hodan even though she was quite younger than him and wether he really died of jaceyl or other causes can only be speculated but he interpreted his illness as jaceyl, thus the poems about his love and its possible that it was jaceyl. We cant deny it unless we have proof to disprove the claims.

[DR-YALAXOOW]

This treath is about the love story more than a man called elmi boodhari existance. The story is fictional.