i think banadir region should be part of hiirshabelle since it cannot be its own state as two or more (pre-1991) regions must make up a member federal state but at the same time they should not be directly be ruled by the corrupt and dysfunctional federal govt for obvious reasons
which leaves being part of hiirshabelle regional state and besides banadir and middle shabelle are both related clan wise
Is galmudug made of two states? It would make sense to join hirshabelle but I doubt reer muqdisho want this to happen. They are 3 million so might as well make their own state
don't say galmudug is a region and half your novice to the Somali politics, per 2016 vision, Galmudug comprises Mudug and Galgaduud this was said by then pm abdi wali yuulka that is why he visited PL him and nick kay to calm down PL. it was agreed to leave the fate of mudug for the Boundaries and Federation Commission wich will mark the boundries between all the states and hirshabelle and southwest and banaadir. this file was left for the current Govt. at that time mjs were sending to this gudi under their daughter asho geele who is very moderate lady and now supported kheyre visit to north GLK as part of his galmudug tour their tribal border. my info says this govt is more pro one intact Mudug first to weaken and divide mj and secondly to bring more darod subclans in the admin and make it look like 50/50 hawiye and darod after leelkase and cumar maxamuud join mx. their third agenda is to make HG and MJ busy on eachother. this will be all done once they control dhusamareeb the capital will be moved to GLK to create a new power sharing beteeen sacad and mx, cumar maxamuud and leelkase. the importance of ceyr and saleebaan will disappear but murursade, dir and weceysle will share gudoonka baarlamaanka.
Banaadir as stand alone state will be plus for HAG. mj Dblocks wanted hiiraan to join galgaduud and banaadir to join jowhar so they can take the capital since PL claims all the harti territories and mj alone have nugaal and bari and nothern mudug. this was going to happen if someone like sh sharif was still there. that is why the constitution doesnt state mogadishu as the capital rather it says itll be decided where the capital...Hiraabist Dam jadeed changed all this and put PL in a defensive position after Galmudug claimed its borders being burtiinle wich is on the border with nugaal. banaadir will have an elected council assembly, mayor and district commisioners and you know only a local son can win this will make it practically a state of its own. biggest mistake Hassan sh done was not doing this in his time otherwise today you will have had an independent mayor. he acually helped HG more than Abgaal.