ANALYSIS: The struggle between Modernists and Tradionalists is generational!

[ReturnOfMariixmaan]

The struggle against traditionalists who are a small elite of the country since independence and the reason the First Republic of Somalia FAILED. Secondly, traditionalists aren’t against state but only in their regions as tribal fiefdoms like the UAE which they openly support their model of confederalism. The traditionalists aren’t modern enough to lead to like a modern state and have democratic standards that is up to par to the rest of the free world. The last 30 years have showed us the regression of the Somali civilization and state. They aren’t for progressive empowerment of the youth, women and ethnic minorities. They are tribal chauvinists who relish on even competing on sub clan level in their fiefdoms. Qabayalad is a onion, that’s the curse of it. But the majority which are youth and 70% of Somalia are modernists and want to build their country, ensure there’s education and healthcare for all not whose Laandheere. Be a normal nation state like the reest of the world. Nepotism and corruption ruined the First Republic and non democratic rule ruined the Second Republic which wasn’t built on the vote of the popular will but through strong man rule. There’s nothing wrong with strong man rule; it must be done through the democratic vote, a plebiscite in truth. But that’s my personal opinion as a modern Bonapartist.

The minimum standard should be ensuring 1m1v as legitimate module for expressing consent to the state and its institutions. The courts should control the excesses of the executive leading the country. There was never a Somali constitution that was agreed on via popular will. We all know the history. The new generation must ensure there’s a ironclad constitution that is sent through a plebiscite and the people know represents their will and aspirations for the Third Republic. The youth are the majority stakeholders and this on a minimum is a majority besides my own opinion. They want development and democratic model of government that is up to first world standards. And I think we are adaptable enough to accomplish. The war against the traditionalists has now started. Enjoy this thread below.


THREAD:

[ReturnOfMariixmaan]

The new generation must oust the old traditional class represented by the transitional class right now in politics. They are the major impediment towards a progressive democratic state that can compete with its neighbors. Understand the Prince clearly, I led by example by turning against my own sub clan interests for the national interest. That’s a what a true patriot does. You have the arms and the vehicles. The choice is yours. Demand 1m1v, do not listen to the old. The Darwinian natural order must return and made men must rule Somalia. Somalia is yours Jaale

[ReturnOfMariixmaan]

The debate isn’t centralist or federalist anymore. The debate is inclusive state building that doesn’t bring back a centralized Somalia nor a federalized one that is centralized for a certain interest group or clique. Fascinating article. Modernists want to create a just and equitable Third Republic that is acceptable to the majority via a plebiscite. The traditionalists who benefited off the blood of the last 30 years are the transitional class that is holding this mature state building back (Deni, Faroole, Madobe, Madasha).

[ReturnOfMariixmaan]

The blowback against federalism is expected. Like there was block back against full on centralism in the 80s. It’s cyclical. I’m a federalist, but I’m NOT for pseudo federalism know as confederation. I still believe in the oneness of Somalia; thus not a elitist traditionalist who seeks the largesse of his tribal regions not the rest of the country. This is the Articles of Confederation moment for Somalia and the federalism project. Only a plebiscite or referendum will decide the future political system and constitution. The traditionalists or the current avatar known as the transitional class will lose this argument. The elites can play games all they want. Elitism and nepotism birthed Revolution:

[BigBreak]

The cursing of oday Farole is uncalled for, you can disagree without being uncivilized.

What tol you belong to determines your political viewpoints in the case of the vast majority of Somalians. Regarding centralization or fragmentation, forget everyone else it seems that within Darod only its Mahamud Saleban and Ogaden vs the rest

[ReturnOfMariixmaan]

Majeerteens and Ogadens hide behind foreigners. No MX will ever see them as their equal; especially a Reer Gedood like me. If I know I can kill you and take your lunch. Why should I respect you? MJs are victims and OGs are slaves of both Amxaaro and Kikuyu. You’re a laangaab Isaaq still bitter over the actions of the last Marehan presidency. I understand your isku dir; unfortunately for you, we don’t give a fuck about you. We don’t border you nor can we kill you if we wanted to. So it’s amusing to me when you try to tell me about our affairs. I don’t have the same energy for yours. That’s the cold blooded zero sum jungle rules I live by. I’m not impressed by your valor as we never fought as a clan mano o mano but your culture and commerce. I respect isaaqs for their business acumen.

[ReturnOfMariixmaan]

Besides the fkd that sidetracked me the incompetence of the transitional class aka traditionalists who from the inception of the First Republic were pro foreigners meddling in our affairs continues today.

THREAD:

[DaahirMursal]

All Somalis, especially the ones within Somalia, instinctively abide by the traditionalist lifestyle taught to them ever since they were an infant. Forcefully removing such a lifestyle - and abruptly as well - will place strains on the minds of our citizens, and will eventually cause chaos & violence to unleash within the country once again.

As Somalia modernizes, it'll slowly leave them. Just like how western kids are seen more 'civilized' and less destructive than their back-home counterparts, when Somalia (from Zeylac to Ras Kamboni) sees proper development and access to basic human needs (food, water, aid, hospitals, etc), we will them witness Somalis living in a more functional society. It takes time, and it'll definitely occur. Patience is what's needed.

[ReturnOfMariixmaan]

These two FMS a threat to genuine state building:

[ReturnOfMariixmaan]

The same cannibals that fathered the TPLF and pushed them on Somalia are now against the nascent Somali democracy. Like Noam Chomsky wisely says: “Democracy is always harmful to elite interests.” The foreign elites want a weak central govt to sign away our natural resources, that’s why the EU finds Farmaajo and NN so threatening:

[ReturnOfMariixmaan]

The foreign stooges can no longer stop the populist wave of NN. This Somali woman has more caqli than our men wallahi. Secondly, this is a generational fight to revive the rights of the people over the elites who sold, killed, and destroyed Somalia since the inception of the Somali state in 1960. Some clans are stooges for gaalo and would sell their women not to be ruled by their fellow Somali (on record btw). That speaks to their gunimo and why they should be isolated from power. THE SOMALI PEOPLE ARE WIDE AWAKE; THE DABODHILIF ELITES WILL LOSE THIS WAR: